Started By
Message
0
Posted on 8/16/09 at 6:17 pm to shawshank39
quote:
he has proven himself in the NFL as the Saints all-time leading rusher despite missing nearly 2 full seasons due to injury....unlike a struggling McFadden who is an NFL bust.
all im reading here is that you have no fricking clue what is going on
Posted on 8/16/09 at 6:18 pm to shawshank39
quote:
.unlike a struggling McFadden who is an NFL bust.
Well give McFadden some credit he isn't playing for the Steelers ya know. Also I think we are talking about their time in college here.
Posted on 8/16/09 at 6:18 pm to tgr4evr
McFadden
Posted on 8/16/09 at 6:19 pm to itawambadog
shawshank is trying to pass wrt for dumbest reb
Posted on 8/16/09 at 6:19 pm to Ross
I think the things that make McFadden's totals more impressive is that he really never played a complete year at Arkansas. Freshman year he did not start immediately, Hillis was the starter. He had a toe issue to begin a year and I think he also had some type of injury before the junior year.
Posted on 8/16/09 at 6:20 pm to Enfuego
You're right woo, my bad. Just under 5,100
Posted on 8/16/09 at 6:20 pm to sms151t
quote:
Injured all season long but through 13 games, injured, he had 499 yards rushing, 285 receiving, and 5 TD's for 784 All-Purpose Yards at 5.52 per touch.
He also made the Cowboys his bitch 3 nights ago.
If that's a "bust", well, so be it.
Posted on 8/16/09 at 6:20 pm to heartbreakTiger
He has his work cut out for him. He's getting close though. 
Posted on 8/16/09 at 6:21 pm to heartbreakTiger
quote:
shawshank is trying to pass wrt for dumbest reb
Don't sell WRT short; he's had his fair share of comments about McFadden in the NFL that are just out of this world stupid.
Posted on 8/16/09 at 6:22 pm to geauxtigahs87
We need a RB bust thread. I have a long list that would bring back memories...and felonies.
Posted on 8/16/09 at 6:23 pm to Sao
quote:
We need a RB bust thread. I have a long list that would bring back memories...and felonies.
Can we include JuJu Harshaw and Cedric Cobbs on that list?
Posted on 8/16/09 at 6:25 pm to Sao
[quote]We need a RB bust thread. I have a long list that would bring back memories...and felonies.
[/quote
cecil the deisel collins
[/quote
cecil the deisel collins
Posted on 8/16/09 at 6:52 pm to sms151t
quote:
Deuce McAllister
I'd give the nod to McFadden based on the production, but Deuce was a very good RB.
Posted on 8/16/09 at 7:30 pm to ljhog
its not even arguable. Darren McFadden would have shattered every record the SEC had had he stayed a fourth year and HE SHARED CARRIES WITH ANOTHER BACK THATS IN THE TOP FIVE AS WELL.
Dmac
Felix
Peyton
greatest backfield in college history,
Dmac
Felix
Peyton
greatest backfield in college history,
Posted on 8/16/09 at 7:34 pm to shawshank39
quote:
shawshank39
I think Deuce is great but calling McFadden a bust after 1 season is a joke. By your own logic, Deuce was a bust when he was out for 2 seasons.
Part of McFadden's challenge will be playing in Oakland. The NFL is all about the team you play on.
Posted on 8/16/09 at 7:51 pm to SLC
For the last ten year I don't think you can argue with the R-Kansas boys. RunDMC was a bad mutherfricker!
Posted on 8/16/09 at 8:17 pm to offshoretrash
quote:
Deuce McAllister and it ain't even close.
Man, I'm the biggest Deuce homer around, and he was fantastic...but he didn't put up the yards that McFadden did. Shaun Alexander to me is the only guy that was close to McFadden in the past 10-12 years.
Posted on 8/16/09 at 8:21 pm to Cruiserhog
quote:
Dmac
Felix
Peyton
greatest backfield in college history,
yeah not really even close though
This post was edited on 8/16/09 at 8:33 pm
Posted on 8/16/09 at 8:21 pm to DeuceisLoose
One addendum to what I posted earlier, however, since the title of the thread could be open to suggestion (that sounds kind of insidious now that I type it). The best running back that I actually saw during that time in the SEC was not McFadden or Alexander (their cumulative careers were the best). It was Cecil Collins. For the few games that he played, he was absolutely, positively unstoppable. It's a shame his head wasn't on straight, although I don't think he could help it. Some people are born with their demons.
Page 2 of 4
Back to top
Follow SECRant for SEC Football News