A.J. McCarron should win Heisman if...

Heisman is the best player in the nation in that year. Not best player on the best team.

He has my vote if his mom wears one of those low cut outfits for the presentation

quote:

---

Well, this is completely false outside of RG3.

---

Surprised you didn't include Manziel in there

We can make that happen

Or Tebow.

quote:

---

Well, this is completely false outside of RG3.

---

You're right.

Manzeil lost 2 games and won it, Tebow lost 3 or 4 games and won it and you already mentioned RG3.

The point is that most of the times these teams are successful because the player is so good. What would have Auburn been without Cam, OU without Bradford and so on.

McCarron is clearly not the best player in the nation.

Thats some bullshite ESPN started with the "best in the nation that year"... i have yet to see any legit documented evidence that that is the sole criteria for the Heisman.

LINK

This is straight from the Heisman Mission Statement from their website... says nothing about single year accomplishment.

JFF dies in a plane crash on the way to New York

He puts his team in better position to win than Manziel. How often does AJ heave a ball and just pray it is caught? Johnny does it multiple times a game. It allowed Bama to build it's 35-14 lead and kept Auburn in the game.

quote:

---

If he throws for 250/3 TD's and 0 picks over the next four games (State, Chattanooga, Auburn, Missouri) then his numbers would be 3000 yards, 31 TDs, 3 picks. That would be impressive. If anything Winston has two more chances to win it.

---

Goddamn Alabama logic.


It doesn't matter if Winston has more chances. If he's the best player, then he should be given the trophy.