Started By
Message
re: Michael Dyer was down
Posted on 1/11/11 at 8:33 pm to CamNeutered
Posted on 1/11/11 at 8:33 pm to CamNeutered
Yes, thanks for finding that. I looked, but didn't find that.
0
Posted on 1/11/11 at 8:34 pm to CamNeutered
Dude, you start shite every day, he clearly wasn't down. GFYS and move out of your parents basement. You're a waste and just trying to start shite.
Posted on 1/11/11 at 8:36 pm to BamaChick
Difference in those to pics is back of hand and palm of hand
Posted on 1/11/11 at 8:37 pm to 7thWardTiger
I know.
I said as much.
But please point out where the rules differentiate between-
-the wrist vs. the hand
and
-the front vs. the back of said hand or wrist
Because the rule posted here does neither.
I said as much.
But please point out where the rules differentiate between-
-the wrist vs. the hand
and
-the front vs. the back of said hand or wrist
Because the rule posted here does neither.
Posted on 1/11/11 at 8:39 pm to CashMoneyProgram
quote:
does the fact the ball hand was down (adams) as opposed to dyer's non ball hand have anythng to do with it?
absolutely
Posted on 1/11/11 at 8:39 pm to Cigars Beer Boobs
Me? I just posted a pic I saw for the guy. I haven't given my opinion on whether I thought he was down or not. I don't start crap nor do I even post very often.
Posted on 1/11/11 at 8:39 pm to BamaChick
Its a stupid "unwritten" rule.
Posted on 1/11/11 at 8:40 pm to Sao
that is funny right there do not care who you are,...
Posted on 1/11/11 at 8:42 pm to HawgAlude
Now...that right there's old!
Posted on 1/11/11 at 8:42 pm to Woopigsooie20
quote:
Its a stupid "unwritten" rule.
frick that.
The refs in general have enough trouble with written rules, much less interpreting unwritten rules.
Posted on 1/11/11 at 8:44 pm to BamaChick
quote:
Because the rule posted here does neither.
quote:
ARTICLE 3. A live ball becomes dead and an official shall sound his whistle or declare it dead:
a. When it goes out of bounds other than a kick that scores after touching the uprights or crossbar, when a ball carrier is out of bounds, or when a ball carrier is so held that his forward progress is stopped. When in question, the ball is dead.
b. When any part of the ball carrier's body, except his hand or foot, touches the ground or when the ball carrier is tackled or otherwise falls and loses possession of the ball as he contacts the ground with any part of his body, except his hand or foot. ...
Link
Posted on 1/11/11 at 8:48 pm to crimsonsaint
Thanks!
So it has nothing to do with what hand the ball is in.
And it doesn't enumerate where the hands and feet end.
It doesn't differentiate between front and back of the hand.
The excuse given for the call in the Sugar Bowl was his wrist is part of the hand, but you can clearly see Dyer's wrist was down, too.
Can someone who says there is a difference between the back and front of the hand find my the rule where it spells out that difference?
So it has nothing to do with what hand the ball is in.
And it doesn't enumerate where the hands and feet end.
It doesn't differentiate between front and back of the hand.
The excuse given for the call in the Sugar Bowl was his wrist is part of the hand, but you can clearly see Dyer's wrist was down, too.
Can someone who says there is a difference between the back and front of the hand find my the rule where it spells out that difference?
Posted on 1/11/11 at 8:48 pm to BamaChick
quote:
But please point out where the rules differentiate between-
-the wrist vs. the hand
and
-the front vs. the back of said hand or wrist
Because the rule posted here does neither.
It's in the Philosophy of the Rules (Proper Application); not the rule book proper.
Posted on 1/11/11 at 8:49 pm to BamaChick
quote:
frick that.
The refs in general have enough trouble with written rules, much less interpreting unwritten rules.
The Yahoo story about the exact same thing says what really is correct.
quote:
either both runners are down, or both are alive. It can't be one or the other.
Posted on 1/11/11 at 8:50 pm to BamaChick
I say neither of them are down.
Hell, D.J.'s doing the one hand up, one hand down gig. I'm saying... one should cancel out the other.
Hell, D.J.'s doing the one hand up, one hand down gig. I'm saying... one should cancel out the other.
Posted on 1/11/11 at 8:51 pm to Cigars Beer Boobs
NOT
Posted on 1/11/11 at 8:51 pm to Woopigsooie20
quote:
either both runners are down, or both are alive. It can't be one or the other.
That's what I've been saying all day.
But, according to our resident ref, there is a Philosophy book that refs follow, in addition to the actual rules.
Posted on 1/11/11 at 8:57 pm to Cigars Beer Boobs
He was definitely down. Good to see some bad calls go to Auburn again this year Even with replay
Even with replay Posted on 1/11/11 at 8:57 pm to BamaChick
Let's say D.J. catches a pass with his hand in that position. Would he be down?
Posted on 1/11/11 at 8:58 pm to Porky
Of course, especially if it was Auburn, LSU, Georgi or Florida...
Page 4 of 5
Popular
Back to top
Follow SECRant for SEC Football News