re: Ending the drama now.

quote:

---

Yes. Do two running plays, one ending after no gain and the other ending after a fifty yard run, both start with a quarterback taking a snap?

---

Great example...except both of those ended with a TD. Are you an idiot? Serious question.

Finally, someone who isn't afraid to state the truth.

I'll try this again. Think of these teams as Teams A, B, C, and D. You don't know the time or score, the teams involved, or the stakes of the game.

Team A misses a field goal. It falls into the end zone. A player for Team B returns it all the way for a touchdown.

Team C misses a field goal. It falls into the end zone. A player for Team D returns it all the way for a touchdown.

I would say it was the same play, wouldn't you?

quote:

---

except both of those ended with a TD

---

Why do you assume the fifty yard run ended with a TD? I was using a random run play to illustrate my point... which you're helping to make, thank you.

Would you say that a game winning field goal in a high school game is the same as a game winning field goal in the Super Bowl? I personally would say they are different, due to the different stress levels involved.

Play against UAB: result of UAB being UAB (Awful)
Play against Bama: top three luckiest plays I've witnessed through a television screen along with Auburns previous game and Bluegrass miracle

Dont ignore mine now...i have a multi step project in the works.

Hell since youre simple minded i will speed it up for you.

A) Both plays start with a kicker attempting a field goal.

B) Both plays involve the kicker missing the field goal and the returner fielding it.

C) Both plays end in said returner returning the missed field goal for 6 points.

All of that equals the plays being the same. Situation/ level of Comp/ Luck are all factors. but the play itself IS the same.

Again its more Bamas fault for letting that play happen than Auburn being lucky to let it happen.

Saban was outcoached on that play/game by the Chiz

quote:

---

Hell i blame georgias db's for that loss

---

i agree

quote:

---

moral victory...thats what auburn is best at as far as im concerned

---

that and beating Bama last year...

Ill give them one as long as we win the sec chsmpionship the next two years

quote:

---

Wrong; how much is on the line, the quality of the opponent, and how much time is left in the game all factor into how "lucky" a play is or isn't.

---

No. You are confusing Lucky with Exciting. Just because a game ends on an exciting play doesn't mean its Lucky. By your definition if Bama had made the FG they would have only won because they were lucky.

A play being lucky is based off of the odds of that play happening in that same situation. You kick a long FG with a bunch of fat boys on the field while the other team is set up to return then the odds of it being returned are pretty high. The UGA pass on the other hand is almost never going to be tipped right into the WR's hands.