re: Eli Manning.. HOF [Yes] or [No]

Maybe in all of your posting accolades you will see it. Remember to check it 11 times

quote:

---

There are several quarterbacks in the HOF who don’t have the accomplishments or stats that he does. Maybe not first ballot but he will get in

---

Agree but the position has changed a great deal. Players from even the 90s don't compare to the players of the 2010s.

Good discussion. I think it’s a debate for sure. My no side is focusing on how that Top 10 status isn’t gonna last long. The 2 rings are most compelling and subjectively, that game/Win was epic and so memorable.

No

Hall of Good

I understand. It’s not like you have that kind of time

I’ll also add, if he had the exact same career but played in Jacksonville, Minnesota or somewhere not NYC or LA, he’d be a lot less likely to get in.

Seeing Darren Sproles on the list giving me big EA Sports NCAA 2003 nostalgia vibes.

Edit: let your opponent pick Oklahoma etc. You pick Kansas St and run the triple option and thanks for playing try again.

N

quote:

---

Two great defenses dragged the opponent down so he only needed to hit a few big passes late in Super Bowls and that is why he will make it to Canton.

---

If you're going to credit the defenses for his Super Bowl success, then you also need to blame his coaches, franchise management, and offensive line for his late-career problems.

Eli was all they had for the last 5 years or so. It was painful watching trying to lead that garbage roster. He was forced into risky situations and that's why his interceptions went sky-high later in his career.

No