Started By
Message
re: When Lane Kiffin gets next HC shot; will he be considered a "Saban Tree" coach?
Posted on 8/29/16 at 10:04 am to genuineLSUtiger
Posted on 8/29/16 at 10:04 am to genuineLSUtiger
Which is really the Norm Chow offense right? Pete has some influence on him just as Saban will, but when I think of coaching tree it is where your roots come from. Just because he came to Bama and has had success coaching with Saban it doesn't change where is main influence started.
Posted on 8/29/16 at 10:07 am to dcbl
I have to think Kiffin will be a very good head coach his next stint.
We all know he can recruit and coach offense, but I feel he will absorb a lot from Saban about how to run a program and build a defense. Those are two areas he was pretty bad at and Saban is the absolute best at.
We all know he can recruit and coach offense, but I feel he will absorb a lot from Saban about how to run a program and build a defense. Those are two areas he was pretty bad at and Saban is the absolute best at.
Posted on 8/29/16 at 10:11 am to bamasgot13
Lane Kiffin systematically burned down trees at every stop he made and all but ruined his coaching career. The fruit from the Pete Carroll/Norm Chow tree was bitter, hard and green.
Saban gave him a shot to rehabilitate his career when no one would touch him with a 10' pole.
"IF" Lane learns from one of the best in the business he may get another opportunity to run his own show again. "IF" he conducts himself in a mature fashion and can field a successful program consistently, then IMO the fruit will be from the Saban tree as it will be seasoned, mature and productive.
Saban gave him a shot to rehabilitate his career when no one would touch him with a 10' pole.
"IF" Lane learns from one of the best in the business he may get another opportunity to run his own show again. "IF" he conducts himself in a mature fashion and can field a successful program consistently, then IMO the fruit will be from the Saban tree as it will be seasoned, mature and productive.
Posted on 8/29/16 at 10:14 am to GregAl
quote:
Absolutely. His coaching career was dead in the water.
I wouldn't go that far. His head coaching career might have been over but he was still respected as an OC.
Posted on 8/29/16 at 10:20 am to TigerFanNKaty
quote:
o me Kiffin would think of Pete Carroll wouldn't he? He cut his teeth out there with Carroll and Norm Chow not with Nick Saban. He's taken what Norm taught him and brought it to Alabama not the other way around. He isn't using what Saban taught him.
I damn sure bet he will take what he has learned from Saban about how to run a successful football program with him to his next job. It might or might not translate to similar results, but you are dumb if you don't think Kiffin has been taking notes on Saban's process. Obviously what he learned from Pete on how to be a HC didn't workout that well.
Posted on 8/29/16 at 10:24 am to dcbl
quote:
When Lane Kiffin gets next HC shot; will he be considered a "Saban Tree" coach?
Is Cam Newton considered an Auburn QB?
He spent 2 years at Florida, a year at Binn, and a year at Auburn. Yet no one says, "former Florida QB Cam Newton..." even though he spent more years in that system than any other.
Posted on 8/29/16 at 10:24 am to TheCaterpillar
quote:
I have to think Kiffin will be a very good head coach his next stint.
We all know he can recruit and coach offense, but I feel he will absorb a lot from Saban about how to run a program and build a defense. Those are two areas he was pretty bad at and Saban is the absolute best at.
His dad is a legendary DC and while some might consider it heresy to say this Monte Kiffin is far more respected than Saban as a defensive mind and that's no knock against Saban. Monte Kiffin is on a whole other level. He is the father of the "The Tampa Cover 2" and his defensive concepts are some of the most influential and widely adopted in all of football -- both college and the NFL.
Monte is the reason UT hired Lane in the first place and we paid Monte the highest assistant salary in all of CFB. While I'm sure he might've picked up some tips from Saban there's no one he could've learned from who is better than his dad.
Posted on 8/29/16 at 10:28 am to Prof
quote:
Monte is the reason UT hired Lane in the first place and we paid Monte the highest assistant salary in all of CFB. While I'm sure he might've picked up some tips from Saban there's no one he could've learned from who is better than his dad.
We are talking about former assistant coaches who go on to be head coaches. Lane Kiffin learned little to nothing about how to be a successful head coach from his dad. I bet he has learned a ton in the last three years.
Posted on 8/29/16 at 10:33 am to dcbl
I think if you see a significant change in Kiffins maturity and the way he handles himself in his next gig will and should be attributed to Saban's mentoring.
Kiffin could be a successful coach learning Saban's process. He can recruit and is pretty good on X's and O's. He was just untamed in his process.
I think the fact Kiffin has remained for 3 years after this season shows he may have grown a lot.
Kiffin could be a successful coach learning Saban's process. He can recruit and is pretty good on X's and O's. He was just untamed in his process.
I think the fact Kiffin has remained for 3 years after this season shows he may have grown a lot.
Posted on 8/29/16 at 10:36 am to Aman
quote:
We are talking about former assistant coaches who go on to be head coaches. Lane Kiffin learned little to nothing about how to be a successful head coach from his dad. I bet he has learned a ton in the last three years.
I'm sure he has learned things about running a program. I was specifically addressing defense. It's been mentioned before in this thread but Kiffin's biggest problem has always been himself -- his own ego and immaturity takes over when he runs things on his own. Saban has kept that in check just as Carrol did and Kiffin has been able to succeed because of that check.
If Kiffin has matured or ever matures as a person he'll be a fine HC and if he has been able to grow up under Saban he'll be a success on his own. The only thing that has ever stood in Lane Kiffin's way is Lane Kiffin.
Posted on 8/29/16 at 10:39 am to dcbl
I would be shocked to see Kiffin get another HC gig. Screwed up Tenn and was humiliatedly (new word) bounced by SC on the tarmack of LAX. Very good OC and recruiter.
Posted on 8/29/16 at 10:46 am to Prof
quote:
Prof
I didn't say scheme a defense, I said build a defense.
I'm sure he learned some Tampa 2 from his dad, but he learned what kind of bodies/players work the best in college football from Saban.
Posted on 8/29/16 at 10:58 am to dcbl
Yes, and likely will have benefited greatly from the experience.
Rodo
Rodo
Posted on 8/29/16 at 10:59 am to TheCaterpillar
quote:
I didn't say scheme a defense, I said build a defense.
I'm sure he learned some Tampa 2 from his dad, but he learned what kind of bodies/players work the best in college football from Saban.
Maybe but he would've learned that from his father as well and under Carrol. If he learns anything from Saban it needs to be maturity, self-discipline, and work ethic -- even how to be a boss and lead others. Those things have been his Achilles' heel rather than a lack of football knowledge.
Posted on 8/29/16 at 11:32 am to TheCaterpillar
He may well develop into a successful college HC but two things will follow him around the rest of his professional life: Al Davis calling him the biggest liar he ever met & all the BS he & his staff did in such a short period of time at UT.
Posted on 8/29/16 at 11:35 am to dcbl
Kiffin may learn to be a CEO under Saban. He was already a good play caller. His dad was a good defensive coordinator with the right players.
He'll be a part of the tree, but every good head coach has to be their own man at some point. Then they can plant their own tree.
Let the games begin. PLEASE!
He'll be a part of the tree, but every good head coach has to be their own man at some point. Then they can plant their own tree.
Let the games begin. PLEASE!
Posted on 8/29/16 at 11:36 am to UCLABRUIN
quote:
I would be shocked to see Kiffin get another HC gig.
he should take notes from daddy and be a lifelong coordinator
Posted on 8/29/16 at 11:37 am to Prof
quote:
If he learns anything from Saban it needs to be maturity, self-discipline, and work ethic -- even how to be a boss and lead others. Those things have been his Achilles' heel rather than a lack of football knowledge.
Good answer.
Posted on 8/29/16 at 11:40 am to NYCAuburn
quote:
should take notes from daddy and be a lifelong coordinator
Not a bad job with the money that's out there now. He's proven if he has good players he can call plays with the best.
Back to top
Follow SECRant for SEC Football News