re: ODB Jr.>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Mike Evans

Ehhh I'll give you that. But he's not that much better than Evans.

Tampa Bay has shitty QB play but it also helped to have Vincent Jackson across from you who was a 1k receiver or close to it. Compared to Eli(two time champ) + RR and co. Can't think of the Giants receivers outside of Cruz + Randle

To me it's a toss up, but my biased ness would make me take Evans. Those 200+ yd games were insane. Rookie hasn't done that since Randyyyyy Moss??

Evans is better. Not hard to appear like a stud when you have a 2 time Super Bowl champ throwing to you. Evans has no one

ODB was better this year no doubt, but you can't act like both situations are the same.

Bucs are last in the league with a bottom five QB.

Evans has twice the yds and TDs if roles were reversed and Evans was on the NYG

Bucs 1st lost their OC, named Marcus Arroyo (a College QBs coach) the OC, had 2 different QBs and was schemed against as the #1 option almost all year

Evans is better and it's not particularly close

mike evans has 12 td's without a 2 time superbowl champ throwing it to him so there definitely is a little doubt

give me the 6'5" freak all day tho and we locked up the #1 pick today!

Like be the GOAT

OBJ can
Evans can't

quote:

---

If Justin Blackmon and Josh Gordon weren't pot heads they would put Odell to shame. OBJ is a fantastic rookie. He isn't a top 10 WR.

---

If...if...if...so stupid. Nobody is putting Beckham to shame this year. That's laughable.

quote:

---

Andre Johnson
Larry Fitzgerald
Wes Welker
Brandon Marshall
Alshon Jeffrey
Jordy Nelson
Antonio Brown
DeSean Jackson
Reggie Wayne
Julian Edelman
Vincent Jackson

I'm sure there are more. OBJ doesn't demand a double team or safety over the top yet. Hes deserves ROY but not a pro bowl selection or a top 10 WR ranking.

---

Have you been frozen and just thawed out? It's 2014. Beckham's numbers dwarf most of those guys you listed. For this year, Beckham has easily been top 10. Nobody has played better at WR since he started playing. Maybe some have been as good, but not better...

People keep talking about him having Eli Manning, but the Giants didn't even have a 1000 yard receiver last year even with Cruz. Beckham has 1300 yards and 12 TDs in 12 games. He ended up with the 2nd most receptions in Giant history. He has had 43 receptions, 606 yards and 7 TDs in his last four games. That's more TDs than AJ Green and Julio Jones have had for the season. In fact, he has had as many TDs as they have had combined. He has easily been one of the best receivers this year and his catches have been phenomenal. He also broke the NFL record for most catches and yards through 12 games for a rookie.

Not even close. The Aggy butthurt doesn't just stop at 0-4..they're reminded every Sunday how much better we are

Aggy butthurt still flowing from Mike Evans getting shut down by a freshman last year..fricking love it.