re: Micah Gibbs...

In comparing a catcher and a player from a different position who are basically equal, it's always going to be the catcher who gets the nod from me. It is incredibly difficult to play that position at the level that Gibbs does. In addition, most catchers can't hit as effectively as Gibbs, either.

An exellent catcher who's a scary hitter is a much rarer thing than a position player with power.