Started By
Message
re: My Solution For a Fair Play-off
Posted on 12/4/23 at 9:16 am to AUstar
Posted on 12/4/23 at 9:16 am to AUstar
quote:
Only myself and Corch have offered a solution.
Do we need a solution when a 12 team playoff begins next year?
The only thing that bothers me a little is giving first round bye games. Players get hurt and that is a massive advantage to not play in the first round.
2
Posted on 12/4/23 at 10:35 am to PubeCrab
Yes there will always need to be a solution when you have a committee determining who is in or out…
Set the rules of how to get in the playoffs if you do that you’re in if you don’t you aren’t.
The whole eye test bullshite and who’s really the better team blah blah blah shite wouldn’t happen we would t even need rankings.
The who is the best team argument got dumped on it head in front of everyone with Washington beating Oregon, Bama beating Georgia. Remember just 1 week ago Georgia was the “best” team and Bama 8th. Now Bama is one of the top 4 and Georgia isn’t.
All that to say opinions shouldn’t matter.
Set the rules of how to get in the playoffs if you do that you’re in if you don’t you aren’t.
The whole eye test bullshite and who’s really the better team blah blah blah shite wouldn’t happen we would t even need rankings.
The who is the best team argument got dumped on it head in front of everyone with Washington beating Oregon, Bama beating Georgia. Remember just 1 week ago Georgia was the “best” team and Bama 8th. Now Bama is one of the top 4 and Georgia isn’t.
All that to say opinions shouldn’t matter.
Posted on 12/5/23 at 6:07 pm to PubeCrab
quote:
Do we need a solution when a 12 team playoff begins next year?
Yes because committees suck. NFL doesn't use committees. They have set rules on what it takes to make playoffs. High-school doesn't use committees as far as I know. College basketball only uses a committee to select a few teams on the bubble - everyone else gets automatic bids based on record.
It is much better (and simpler) to just crown division/conference champs (based solely on record) and put those teams in the playoff. Not sure why that is so hard for NCAA to understand. Only thing I can figure is they want the committee so it can be rigged (there's big money involved). There is zero other reason to have a committee.
Page 1 of 1
Latest Auburn News
Back to top
Follow SECRant for SEC Football News