Started By
Message
2
Posted on 6/7/16 at 11:54 am to AlabamaAlum07
seen me do what? I answered your question, I also notice you didn't even acknowledge the second part where you were intentionally misleading.
Posted on 6/7/16 at 11:55 am to BAMAisDIESEL09
Well let's see, one won national championship, the other did not, so..... yeah.
Posted on 6/7/16 at 11:57 am to AlabamaAlum07
Lot of games Murray showed up for and his defense flat out just sucked. For example in 2011 vs South Carolina, Murray throws close to 250 yards, 4 TDs, and only 1 INT, but they lose 45-42.
Their other big game vs South Carolina in 2012, the whole team got destroyed 35-7 in a hostile environment.
Murray didn't blow a lot of big games, it was more of a Richt issue than anything.
Their other big game vs South Carolina in 2012, the whole team got destroyed 35-7 in a hostile environment.
Murray didn't blow a lot of big games, it was more of a Richt issue than anything.
Posted on 6/7/16 at 11:58 am to Porter Osborne Jr
Did they? Asking for a friend.
Posted on 6/7/16 at 12:08 pm to Gary Busey
quote:
I would have taken Murray straight up in 2011. A year under his belt, he scrambled well, and the oline was still sick that year. Of course the defense the main reason Bama won it that year, but having a QB with a year under his belt would have been great. McCarron started to catch on right around when Brad Smedley became the big target.
quote:
It's a good discussion, though it's still hard to predict because Alabama runs a different system than Georgia, so we don't know if Murray would have been free to do similar stuff. McCarron in 2011 was much different in 2012, when he had a 30-3 TD-INT ratio.
UGA needed Murray to have big games to win and Bama needed McCarron to be a game manager. Murray is a pretty smart player and I think he could have settled in as a game manger if he needed.
Posted on 6/7/16 at 12:09 pm to Gary Busey
quote:
That SECCG though was the shite
Posted on 6/7/16 at 12:09 pm to Gary Busey
quote:
Lot of games Murray showed up for and his defense flat out just sucked. For example in 2011 vs South Carolina, Murray throws close to 250 yards, 4 TDs, and only 1 INT, but they lose 45-42.
That works both ways though. He played like arse against Florida in 2012 but the defense bailed him out.
Posted on 6/7/16 at 12:10 pm to elit4ce05
quote:
Did they?
If you have to ask, you can't afford it.
Posted on 6/7/16 at 12:13 pm to Porter Osborne Jr
Georgia beats Alabama in the 2012 SEC Championship
They go on to win the title vs Notre Dame
Mark Richt is still the head coach of Georgia
They go on to win the title vs Notre Dame
Mark Richt is still the head coach of Georgia
Posted on 6/7/16 at 12:13 pm to hg
They probably would've found some way to lose to ND.
Posted on 6/7/16 at 12:14 pm to BAMAisDIESEL09
Murray/Gurley. They are better players on a worse team. Bama's OL and defense with Murray and Gurley would have gotten them into the national championship several times.
Posted on 6/7/16 at 12:21 pm to AlabamaAlum07
He was also incredible against Auburn in 2013; lead the team to a 21 point 4th quarter comeback but still lost because of a hail mary.
Cherrypicking bad games doesn't mean anything. Both QBs had great college careers, but they still had bad games from time to time.
Cherrypicking bad games doesn't mean anything. Both QBs had great college careers, but they still had bad games from time to time.
Posted on 6/7/16 at 12:25 pm to BAMAisDIESEL09
Isn't the point of having good players to win championships?
That's the ultimate goal right? Win games, win titles?
It's not just a circle jerk talent exhibition, the point is to win.
I'll take the players who know how to win.
That's the ultimate goal right? Win games, win titles?
It's not just a circle jerk talent exhibition, the point is to win.
I'll take the players who know how to win.
Posted on 6/7/16 at 12:27 pm to IAmReality
Exactly. McCarron was BCS title game MVP whereas Murray was...TaxSayler Bowl MVP. 
Posted on 6/7/16 at 12:28 pm to AlabamaAlum07
quote:
That works both ways though. He played like arse against Florida in 2012 but the defense bailed him out.
But was that because Georgia's defense was that good, or because Florida's offense was that bad? Remember that was a Florida team that led by Will Muschamp and Jeff Driskel as the QB. Florida also had a good defense that year too, but was atrocious on offense. They got blown out vs Louisville in the Sugar Bowl.
Posted on 6/7/16 at 12:29 pm to Gary Busey
A little bit of both. Jarvis Jones was a monster.
Posted on 6/7/16 at 12:35 pm to thatdude1985
quote:
be honest hg...is it because you hate Alabama and that's making your answer biased? If not then disregard what I said and carry on.
If you want honesty, you'll just have to realize this question was never going to end well for Bama. There are people who honestly believe Murray/Gurley would be better. Then there are just as many, if not more, people who would not pass up a chance to annoy Bama fans by picking Murray/Gurley. This is the sort of post that shouldn't be made because everyone already knows how it will go.
I'd pick McCarronLacy myself. They won a national title. Not really much else to aspire toward with any QB/RB combo.
Posted on 6/7/16 at 12:42 pm to randomways
quote:
I'd pick McCarronLacy myself. They won a national title. Not really much else to aspire toward with any QB/RB combo.
So then you would pick Trent Dilfer over Dan Marino since he won the Super Bowl and Marino did not.
Page 5 of 6
Popular
Back to top
Follow SECRant for SEC Football News