Defintive Derek Barnett vs Myles Garrett Comparison Thread

Myles Garrett is overrated. I will show you why with cold hard stats:

DB: 189 TK 50.0 TFL 31 SK

MG: 144 TK 48.0 TFL 32.5 SK

So DB leads MG in tackles by a longshot, but MG leads TFLs and SKs by a slim margin. Now lets break those down vs SEC Competition:

DB: 129 TK 41 TFL 28 SK

MG: 86 TKL 23.5 TFL 12 SK

WOW! So in SEC competition, DB wins in TKs by a wide margin, and now he nearly doubles MG's TFLs and nearly triples his sacks! Something must be up, lets take a look at who these players got their sacks against to see who showed out against tough competition:

Sack by Teams:

DB

Florida x3
Ole Miss x3
South Carolina x6
Kentucky x5
Vandy x3
Oklahoma
Georgia x3
Alabama x2
South Carolina
North Texas
Northwestern
TAMU
Mizzou

MG

South Carolina x3
Lamar x2
Rice x2.5
Miss St x2
Ole Miss
Louisiana Monroe x 3.5
West Virginia x .5
ASU x2
Nevada x3
Arkansas
LSU
Louisville
UCLA
Auburn x2
VOLS
UT - San Antonio x 4.5




Conclusion: Forget about the West vs East argument, this is a player vs player argument. Its a proven fact. Derek Barnett (the best Defensive lineman if not player in college football) shows out against tough competition. Myles Garrett is a Marshmallow. DB being snubbed for the Bednarik is a joke.



SOURCE