re: Could an All-SEC team beat an All-American team

QB Cam Newton Auburn
RB Marcus Lattimore USCe
RB Steven Ridley LSU
WR AJ Green UGA
WR Julio Jones Alabama
WR Alshon Jeffrey USCe
TE DJ Williams Arkansas
OL DeMarcus Love Arkansas
OL Derrick Sherrod Miss State
OL Lee Ziemba Auburn
OL Clint Boling Alabama
OL Mike Pouncey Florida
DE Marcel Dareus Alabama
DT Nick Fairley Auburn
DT Drake Nevis LSU
DE Sam Montgomery(healthy) LSU/Barkavious Mingo LSU/Pernell McPhee Ole Miss
LB Donta Hightower(100%) Alabama
LB Kelvin Sheppard LSU
LB Justin Houston UGA
CB Patrick Peterson LSU
CB Janoris Jenkins Florida
FS Amhad Black Florida
SS Mark Baron (healthy) Alabama

vs.

QB Andrew Luck Stanford
RB LaMichael James Oregon
RB Kendall Hunter Oklahoma State
WR Justin Blackmon Oklahoma State
WR Jonathan Baldwin Pittsburgh
WR Ryan Broyles Oklahoma
TE Lance Kendricks Wisconsin
OL Gabe Carimi Wisconsin
OL Nate Soldier Colorado
OL Rodney Hudson FSU
OL Orlando Franklin Miami
OL Jake Kirkpatrick TCU
DE Da'Quan Bowers Clemson
DT Stephen Phae Oregon State
DT Corey Liuget Illinois
DE Ryan Kerrigan Purdue
LB Von Miller Texas A&M
LB Greg Jones Michigan State
LB Akeem Ayers UCLA
CB Prince Amukamara Nebraska
CB Brandon Harris Miami
FS Rahim Moore UCLA
SS Robert Sands West Virginia

Matches up pretty I'd say