Started By
Message
Grade everyone and everything
Posted on 8/31/14 at 1:30 pm
Posted on 8/31/14 at 1:30 pm
Sims: B-
Backs: A
OL: A
WRs: B+
DL: B-
LBs: C-
Secondary: D+
K/P: A
Kiffin: A
Smart: C+
Backs: A
OL: A
WRs: B+
DL: B-
LBs: C-
Secondary: D+
K/P: A
Kiffin: A
Smart: C+
9
Posted on 8/31/14 at 1:33 pm to AllBamaDoesIsWin
quote:
Sims: C
Backs: A
OL: A
WRs: A-
DL: B-
LBs: C-
Secondary: D-
K/P: A
Kiffin: A-
Smart: C
Posted on 8/31/14 at 1:34 pm to AllBamaDoesIsWin
If smart gets a C what does Saban get?
Posted on 8/31/14 at 1:36 pm to Patton
quote:
If smart gets a C what does Saban get?
Tougher to grade Saban. I'll say B
Posted on 8/31/14 at 1:37 pm to AllBamaDoesIsWin
I guess that's fair.
Posted on 8/31/14 at 1:40 pm to AllBamaDoesIsWin
Sims: C+ (He did well for what he can do. I just wish he was capable of more.)
Backs: A (no fumbles
)
OL: A- (Leon Brown's penalties keep it from an A)
WRs: B (Christion Jones
)
DL: C+ (Was hoping Trickett would look a little less comfortable in the pocket)
LBs: C-
Secondary: D (I don't think Collins solid performance can mask a terrible performance by Sylve, average performance by Cyrus, meh by Jarrick, meh by Perry. I saw a quote on twitter today that talked about us only having one real nfl talent in the secondary on the field yesterday. Eye opening for sure.
K/P: Av
Kiffin: A Choochoo Bitches.
Smart: C
Backs: A (no fumbles
) OL: A- (Leon Brown's penalties keep it from an A)
WRs: B (Christion Jones
) DL: C+ (Was hoping Trickett would look a little less comfortable in the pocket)
LBs: C-
Secondary: D (I don't think Collins solid performance can mask a terrible performance by Sylve, average performance by Cyrus, meh by Jarrick, meh by Perry. I saw a quote on twitter today that talked about us only having one real nfl talent in the secondary on the field yesterday. Eye opening for sure.
K/P: A
v Kiffin: A Choochoo Bitches.
Smart: C
Posted on 8/31/14 at 1:45 pm to AllBamaDoesIsWin
quote:
Sims: B
Backs: A
OL: B
WRs: A- (one big arse drop)
DL: C
LBs: C
Secondary: D K/P: A+
Kiffin: A-
Smart: D
special teams: D
Posted on 8/31/14 at 2:07 pm to AllBamaDoesIsWin
quote:
Sims: B+
Backs: A+
OL: A+
WRs: B+...would be an A+ if not for the Jones drop and the Cooper block in the back
DL: B-
LBs: C-
Secondary: D+
P: A+
PK: A+
KO: B-...would be an A+ if not for the long return. That play kept them in the game and immediately reversed the momentum. But the coverage team will be fine, and Griffith is outstanding.
Kiffin: A
Smart: C+ not sure about this...don't know how much of it is on him and how much of it is on the personnel.
Posted on 8/31/14 at 4:52 pm to AllBamaDoesIsWin
Sims: B-
Backs: A+
OL/TE: A-
WRs: A-
DL: B
LBs: C+
DBs (excluding Sylve): C+
Sylve: F
K/P: A+
Backs: A+
OL/TE: A-
WRs: A-
DL: B
LBs: C+
DBs (excluding Sylve): C+
Sylve: F
K/P: A+
Posted on 8/31/14 at 4:57 pm to imraged
Best RB DUO in the country. Henry needs to be the bell cow.
Posted on 8/31/14 at 4:59 pm to AllBamaDoesIsWin
Sims: A for sims, C for what we expect and need at QB for the future
Backs: A+
OL: A would be A+ but brown was fricking up
WRs: A coop and white went off. Chris jones wasn't good
DL: B reed Dickson and Allen stood out. Reed made an impact
LBs: C- Reggie made a couple good plays. Reuben looked lost and arm tackled everyone. Depriest and Ragland will be good with reuben filling in a little at a time.
Secondary: F- except for LC and Geno. and Cyrus was ok. Bradley sylve makes a 0 out of 100 if it were a grade. Brings the average down.
K/P: A+++
ST- F
Kiffin: A would be A+ if it weren't for the fade in the endzone on 2nd and 2.
Smart: C-
Saban: B
Backs: A+
OL: A would be A+ but brown was fricking up
WRs: A coop and white went off. Chris jones wasn't good
DL: B reed Dickson and Allen stood out. Reed made an impact
LBs: C- Reggie made a couple good plays. Reuben looked lost and arm tackled everyone. Depriest and Ragland will be good with reuben filling in a little at a time.
Secondary: F- except for LC and Geno. and Cyrus was ok. Bradley sylve makes a 0 out of 100 if it were a grade. Brings the average down.
K/P: A+++
ST- F
Kiffin: A would be A+ if it weren't for the fade in the endzone on 2nd and 2.
Smart: C-
Saban: B
This post was edited on 8/31/14 at 5:01 pm
Posted on 8/31/14 at 5:29 pm to thatdude1985
quote:
Best RB TRIO in the country.
FIFY
Posted on 8/31/14 at 5:36 pm to pvilleguru
TRUE DAT.
Posted on 8/31/14 at 6:27 pm to AllBamaDoesIsWin
quote:
Sims: B-
Backs: A
OL: A
WRs: B+
DL: B-
LBs: C-
Secondary: D+
K/P: A
Kiffin: A
Smart: C+
Seems about right
Posted on 8/31/14 at 7:00 pm to chattabama
quote:twitter, the fount of all knowledge
I saw a quote on twitter today that talked about us only having one real nfl talent in the secondary on the field yesterday. Eye opening for sure.
Posted on 8/31/14 at 7:08 pm to WeBleedCrimson
Agree with everything except K/P. That's an A+ for sure.
Posted on 8/31/14 at 7:16 pm to bamabenny
I went A because of the KO return for a TD. That's on the coverage I know, and it was probably one of those situations where Saban told him to kick it where they'd return it, but if it was a touchback no KO return. 
I'm getting picky I know.
I'm getting picky I know.
Posted on 8/31/14 at 7:23 pm to AllBamaDoesIsWin
QB.B+ Sims did extremely well for his first start, led 3 td drives, moved the chains, was mostly responsible for our very high 3rd down conversion %, made a few mistakes but was for the most part a big assest, and im kind of surprised to read all the negativity about him until I remember that we really do have the shitiest fanbase around
WR. A. Great for the most part, had a few drops
RB. A+ Fantastic, just need to keep it up, maybe feed drake some to the outside to change it up
OL. B++ Opened big holes for rbs but killed some drives with penalties. Didnt allow a sack, but at least half of the credit for that goes to sims
TE. B did great blocking, need to get involved more in passing game (only time I remember a te getting targeted was the pick)
CB. C. Dont reall have our most physically gifted or talented players out there, need jackson back and TB, need to be more physical against hunh passing to mess up timing, need to tackle better in open field
LB. C+ Problems mostly due to confusion, should improve when depriest returns. Contributed to shutting down run
DL. B Got about as much rush as you can when wrs are running free and ball comes out in 2 seconds. Completrly stuffed run game.
S. B. LC is an all american, best safety inthr country. Perry and williams are solid. Some of the softness in the zone was communcation issues with lbs.
P. A+ punter is a weapon for us this year
K. A+ if griffith had been kicking this well last year and played over foster we would be going for 4 in a row this year
OC. A Kiffin is a much better game caller than nuss
DC. B- Defense overall has room for improvement, but I think noone else this year holds the WV offense to 1 offensive touchdown. They look vastly improved.
WR. A. Great for the most part, had a few drops
RB. A+ Fantastic, just need to keep it up, maybe feed drake some to the outside to change it up
OL. B++ Opened big holes for rbs but killed some drives with penalties. Didnt allow a sack, but at least half of the credit for that goes to sims
TE. B did great blocking, need to get involved more in passing game (only time I remember a te getting targeted was the pick)
CB. C. Dont reall have our most physically gifted or talented players out there, need jackson back and TB, need to be more physical against hunh passing to mess up timing, need to tackle better in open field
LB. C+ Problems mostly due to confusion, should improve when depriest returns. Contributed to shutting down run
DL. B Got about as much rush as you can when wrs are running free and ball comes out in 2 seconds. Completrly stuffed run game.
S. B. LC is an all american, best safety inthr country. Perry and williams are solid. Some of the softness in the zone was communcation issues with lbs.
P. A+ punter is a weapon for us this year
K. A+ if griffith had been kicking this well last year and played over foster we would be going for 4 in a row this year
OC. A Kiffin is a much better game caller than nuss
DC. B- Defense overall has room for improvement, but I think noone else this year holds the WV offense to 1 offensive touchdown. They look vastly improved.
This post was edited on 8/31/14 at 7:27 pm
Page 1 of 1
Latest Alabama News
Popular
Back to top
Follow SECRant for SEC Football News