re: Rank the SEC Heisman winners

quote:

---

Kings of Summer

Alabama arguably has the two most undeserving Heisman winners

---

The problem with this argument is that there is a context of competition. I think you actually could make this argument about Ingram but the field was very weak that year. IMHO Henry absolutely deserved it and even though the competition was stronger, he also came up HUGE in big games down the stretch and earned it.

So in my mind, it is rather difficult to make this statement without a candid discussion of who deserved it more, and clearly so. That's a very tough thing to do for both of those years.