re: Should Chaney stay or should he go? (Long)

quote:

---

The offense scored two more TDs in 2015 than 2016. I don't see the improvement.

---

Considering the circumstances? The OL, WRs, Freshman QB? I would say he must have done an amazing job considering those limitations. Did I get frustrated with the runs straight up the middle? yes.

I'm surprised that Kirby gets a total pass and Chaney gets crucified.

When I criticized Kirby for in game decisions, he was defended based on those circumstances. Why does Kirby get a pass and Chaney gets run out of town on a rail? They faced the exact same circumstances (Save that Kirby was a first year HC)


DO NOT MISUNDERSTAND ME. I think Kirby and the team showed a lot of progress as the season went along. Chaney does deserve some criticism. I am not arguing that he does not. However, IMO, I think Chaney gets a lot of criticism because people from other fan bases "warned" us about him.

quote:

---

Or are you talking about the 100 or so more yards that didn't amount to anything?

---

I don't know that they didn't amount to anything. They may have resulted in 2-3 TD that won us games. I mean, it's silly to say 100+ yards meant everything or meant nothing. What I am saying is if we say Kirby was coaching at a disadvantage compared to last season because of the OL, WRs drops, etc. then shouldn't Chaney get the same consideration?

I think we will see massive improvements next season with a more solid OL, new WRs in addition to Riley and Wims and another year fo experience for eason.

I guess my main point was to those that were wishing he were fired after this season. Seems very premature considering the circumstances.