re: Alabama in top 3 sports

quote:

---

He has said more than once in this thread that all time wins don't matter - that the only thing they're good for is getting you to the post season, which is the only thing that matters.

---

You are correct. That is all wins are good for. If Team A finishes 20-10 for ten consecutive seasons but misses the NCAA Tournament every year, where has than gotten them?

Meanwhile Team B may go 15-15 on five occasions... and 21-9 on five more occasions, with 5 NCAA Tournament appearances.

After 10 seasons, Team A will have 200 wins. Team B will have just 180 wins and 5 NCAA Tournament appearances. No one will care about Team A's win total compared to Team B.

Not. One. Single. Person.

quote:

---

If the only criteria we're using to judge programs is success in post season play, then my post is just as valid.

---

No it isn't. Because it contradicts what I had already posted. Using NCAA Tournament success, Michigan State is far more successful all-time than Florida, but you lied and tried to make it look like I thought the opposite.

Which was even more laughable considering I had already given my rankings earlier and it said the opposite of what you made up. You lose!