re: having 2 five star qb's is like having 2 girlfriends

Process of elimination isn't always a bad thing. Sure, the QB who loses out will have hard feelings, but having top players in separate classes is a good idea. LSU has done it. Hell, look at the RBs under Saban. Either the losing player transfers out after the better player has proven his worth, or the younger one waits his turn. Obviously, having both QBs transfer out is a clusterfrick for TAMU, but that just means something else went wrong, not that it was an innately bad idea.