eye:

Here is an opinion that I know is shared with a lot of others if not on this low brow message board. On this board, you have rivalry denigration such that LSU fans and Ole Miss fans are not going to give any credit due to their rival's RB:

RE: Heisman and other awards, Cook is seen as a character problem in a program where character doesn't matter and in a time with his particular issue is at the forefront of everyone's mind. Yes, JW won it anyway, but it was because he clearly was the best player and was not indicted for rape.

As for who is better, it is subjective. But, I think most people think he runs against weak defenses. The ACC is a poor defensive conference and has been for quite some time. The game SEC fans are interested in are those that provide some comparison to good defenses, especially considering LF and DH play in the SEC and all 3 played Florida and gained about the same number of yards- which provides a direct comparison for the position of RB. The only comparable sample is Cook's game against Florida.

Here is where the story of the statistics help.

Against Florida, LF and DH gained their yards when the game was in doubt, when they needed to be their best, and when possessions were paramount, and first downs were needed.

Against Florida, Dalvin Cook gained 125 yards after the 7:38 mark in the 4th quarter. The game was already over. Florida had pulled many of their defensive starters who were nursing injuries and anticipating of having the game the following week. In fact, Cook gained 77 yards after the 3:26 mark left in the game. Cook was only in the game to gain statistics. The game was long settled and there was no threat of Florida being able to win that game. When in mattered, he was bottled-up except for 1 32 yard run.

So, as far as the SEC view is concerned, everyone thinks he is a good running back. But, few think he is better than LF or DH, because he really isn't. And, he didn't prove he was better in any way. And, there is no doubt that he played against worse defenses. The rest of the nation agrees with the SEC.

As for just yardage volume, DH did not play several quarters of his games. LF missed an entire game when their first game was cancelled and also several quarters of other games, and DC missed time due to injury.

This post was edited on 12/10/15 at 2:58 pm