Started By
Message

re: The most difficult title defenses in college sports?

Posted on 5/23/15 at 9:14 pm to
Posted by randomways
North Carolina
Member since Aug 2013
12988 posts
Posted on 5/23/15 at 9:14 pm to
quote:

There's what, 350 D1 basketball teams?


Practically speaking, though, there are only 32 teams with a shot (based on 8 seed Nova in 1985) to win it all, and even that's a stretch.
Posted by nc14
La Jolla
Member since Jan 2012
28193 posts
Posted on 5/23/15 at 9:40 pm to
Uh, understand title defense?
Posted by DorchesterGamecock
Bristol, CT
Member since May 2014
793 posts
Posted on 5/23/15 at 9:57 pm to
Basketball for sure, the NCAA tournament is a gauntlet and it's cutthroat as heck. There's no losers bracket to fight your way through... then I would say baseball. And I say baseball because out of all three sports its the one sport where David (little schools) ALWAYS has a legitimate shot at slaying Goliath (big schools). The parity in college baseball these last few years makes repeating champions nowadays a way bigger accomplishment than when Southern Cal did it back in the 70s or even when LSU did it in the 90's. That's why it was such a big deal when Oregon State did it in '06-'07 or when South Carolina made it to the CWS finals three years in a row (in '10,'11,'12) and won twice. And the trend of parity in baseball will only continue...

Football is so top heavy that in all honesty there are only about 10 teams that could win back to back titles realistically.
Posted by randomways
North Carolina
Member since Aug 2013
12988 posts
Posted on 5/23/15 at 10:06 pm to
quote:


Basketball for sure, the NCAA tournament is a gauntlet and it's cutthroat as heck. There's no losers bracket to fight your way through... then I would say baseball. And I say baseball because out of all three sports its the one sport where David (little schools) ALWAYS has a legitimate shot at slaying Goliath (big schools). The parity in college baseball these last few years makes repeating champions nowadays a way bigger accomplishment than when Southern Cal did it back in the 70s or even when LSU did it in the 90's. That's why it was such a big deal when Oregon State did it in '06-'07 or when South Carolina made it to the CWS finals three years in a row (in '10,'11,'12) and won twice. And the trend of parity in baseball will only continue...

Football is so top heavy that in all honesty there are only about 10 teams that could win back to back titles realistically.


Pretty good analysis. Basketball also seems to have more Cinderellas in recent years than in times past. I'm sure statistics will muddle, if not outright refute, my claim here, but it still feels that way.

I am hoping people who follow non-Big 3 sports more than most of us will have some thoughts to offer too. Gymnastics, golf, soccer, Quidditch, the path to repeating in sports like those also interests me. I know, for instance, the UNC women's soccer has been absolutely dominant over the last 30 years, but the gap is getting smaller as more schools devote greater attention to recruiting and developing players, so repeating is getting a bit harder (though it's almost always the same 5-6 teams rising to the top still.)

quote:

In the last 25 years, baseball has had 3 sets of repeat champions (USC, Oregon State, and LSU). Football has had 2 sets in the same time frame (Nebraska and Bama). Basketball also had 2 sets (Florida and Duke)


Sorry, I missed this the first time through. Thanks for the specifics. Do you think, as DorrchesterGamecock suggests above, that the title defenses are getting harder? Sports aren't static, so success can get harder or easier over time.
This post was edited on 5/23/15 at 10:10 pm
Posted by skrayper
21-0 Asterisk Drive
Member since Nov 2012
31741 posts
Posted on 5/23/15 at 11:05 pm to
Regular season - Football. No room for errors, anything more than a single loss and your chances drop to nil.

Postseason - Basketball. The lack of a loser's bracket means that once that part of the season has started, it's all or nothing. I suppose that would apply to any single-elimination sport. After that, probably baseball/softball.
Posted by scrooster
Resident Ethicist
Member since Jul 2012
39466 posts
Posted on 5/23/15 at 11:33 pm to
SCAR defended .... almost three-peated against three different teams.

Baseball, football, basketball, ... all of them are tough to repeat much less three-peat.
Page 1 2
Jump to page
first pageprev pagePage 2 of 2Next pagelast page
refresh

Back to top
logoFollow SECRant for SEC Football News
Follow us on Twitter and Facebook to get the latest updates on SEC Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitter