re: Is Sims a better QB than McCarron?

quote:

---

better deep ball NO..

---

quote:

---

I love Sims and he has been a pleasant surprise but he won't get drafted

---

Disagree.

quote:

---

Sims has benefited greatly from Kiffin and a SUPREMELY talented Amari Cooper.

---

AJ had Cooper for two years. Kiffin sets the plays up, sure, but he isn't the one throwing the ball.

quote:

---

AJ is one of the best Bama QB's of all time and was a Heisman trophy finalist.

---

Blake would've been a Heisman finalist last year too.

quote:

---

If he had Kiffin as his coordinator and was allowed to play more wide open, he could have put up even better numbers.

---

I mean, I guess, but AJ threw it plenty last year and in 2012. There still is no way to know that.

quote:

---

Again I'm not knocking Sims, he has probably won a few games for us and is a good QB but AJ is much better.

---

I just don't buy this. Numbers don't prove this. Really the only argument I see is that Blake had a different OC than McCarron.


***I'm enjoying this discussion, and I respect you guys's opinions***