re: Who would you start? (high school stats)

My point in this is that Hill knows how to work within an offense better than Manziel did and didn't have to do everything, yet put up similar numbers.

In 2010, the rest of the team combined outrushed Hill by over 2,300 yards. A senior RB had 1,500+ yards that season.

In 2011, the rest of the team combined outrushed Hill by just under 200 yards.

In 2012, the rest of the team combined outrushed hill by almost 2,000 yards.

Contrast that to Manziel:

In 2008, Manziel had almost 1/3 of the team's total offense.

In 2009, Manziel had the entire team's rushing total (if MaxPreps is correct)

In 2010, Manziel outrushed the rest of his team combined by 1100 yards

Hill is more likely to work within the offense and doesn't feel the need to win the game by himself.