re: Recruiting Class Hypothetical

It just depends on if this is replicated four years or just a one special year. If it's the former then take the one with all the five stars. 4 years of that and that team is special. 4 years of 18+ four stars will lead to a ton of attrition an unhappy kids. But if it's the latter then I think in the long run a class with 18 four stars is better