re: Paul Finebaum claims AJ McCarron is....

quote:

---

I guess we'll have to and bump this thread next January after AJ gets drafted 1st overall and takes a 2-14 team to 11-5 and a playoff berth then, won't we? That'll be a fair comparison then.

---

Or how he didn't win a single thing of importance as the QB at Stanford, a team that won the PAC12 after he left?

Again we are talking about College Football and you guys keep presenting a stupid one sided argument so I am giving you another stupid one sided argument.

AJ has done a lot more than being a game manager, in fact he is the ONLY QB to win even two BCS titles as a starter and he has a chance for three with four overall.

You guys bring up stats but what stats? After all was not Luck the QB?

So AJ beats Luck out with

Passing Efficiency
TD/INT Ratio
Yards per attempt
Wins
Championships

See if you guys can pick and choose facts then anyone can. What makes a QB better? Wins? Stats? Because other than raw production (which is influenced by offensive style, game progression, opponent strengh) everything you would use to judge two pro style QBs, McCarron has better stats than Luck.

But then again he is just a game manager.