re: Birmingham News Preseason All-SEC Team

quote:

---

Brad Wing is the best punter in the nation and that's not an opinion. If you've watched him there really is no argument

---

Yeah, I'd say there is a good argument.
Okay, you want to base it PURELY on net yards per punt? Guess Wing is running down there and making the tackle too? No, and neither is Breeding.
The ONLY way either affects the net yards per punt is MAYBE hang time. Maybe. Unfortunately, I haven't seen a stat for that to confirm.

I said Wing is good, but he's certainly no better than Breeding by any INDIVIDUAL stat that I can find.

And shite no, I don't hang out at Hogville so I haven't been arguing in that thread.