re: What's wrong with Auburn's Defense?

quote:

---

Was it not AU fans that bragged about chizick's Thorpe winners?

---

If you mean Chizik, well than, that's different.

TD experts have now changed my opinion. It was obviously Tommy Tuberville that coached Carlos Rogers as a Thorpe winner. Therefore, Mack Brown was responsible for Michael Huff winning the Thorpe award at Texas.

But wait, you say that Mack Brown was a WR coach then OC before becoming a HC? No worries. Georgia, LSU, & and Florida fans have confirmed that the OC, Gary Crowton, Mike Bobo & Steve Addazio, were responsible for their awful offenses instead of the HC.

Wait a second. That doesn't make any sense. We have TD experts contradicting each other. One group says that the HC is responsible for their respective field and the other says they are not.

I am confused.

Les Miles was an OC at OSU before becoming the HC at LSU, yet his offenses at LSU have ranked near the bottom of the NCAA for the last two years. Why was Gary Crowton fired? It's obviously Miles fault.
Mark Richt was an OC at ECU & FSU before becoming the HC at UGA, yet his offenses at UGA have been widely criticized for the past few years. Why is Mike Bobo getting the blame? It's obviously Richt's fault.
Urban Meyer coached WRs, TEs, & QBs before becoming the HC at BG, Utah, & UF, yet his offense in 2010 was a huge failure. Why did Steve Addazio get the blame from UF fans? It's obviously Urban's fault.


Can you tell me the correct way of thinking. Is it the HC's responsibility to coach their respective field (offense or defense)? Or does it fall on the coordinator?