Started By
Message
After 4 weeks....rank the SEC coaches
Posted on 9/27/10 at 10:43 pm
Posted on 9/27/10 at 10:43 pm
Of course the homer in me wants to think Petrino is near the top but I hold him somewhat responsible for our loss vs. bama. I know he coached a less talented team to a near victory, but I cant escape the lack of a running game. We CANNOT turn the corner without it...so here goes
1. Saban......obvious
2. Meyer......Is he ranked so high because of past success? We find out Saturday
3. Chiz.......I laughed at this hire initially...not so much now
4. Miles.....IF he would hire an OC that could develop a QB he would be ranked higher (but LSU was my pick to win the West this year)
5. Petrino...want to put him higher, but this ain't the Big East (BUT, no one outside of Ark. understands how little he had to work with when he arrived here and just how far he has come)
6. Dooley....Not sure why, but I really think he is a good one
7. Richt...things aren't looking good, but I think Bobo is a BIG part of his problems
8. Nutt....good god, i have been dealing with this man for half my life and still can't figure him out
9. Phillips....See #6
10. Spurrier...think he has lost it (pulling his starter on the last drive only reinforces my thoughts)
11. Mullen, could very easily be as high as 6-7, just haven't seen enough to convince me yet
12. Caldwell...funny guy but out of his league
1. Saban......obvious
2. Meyer......Is he ranked so high because of past success? We find out Saturday
3. Chiz.......I laughed at this hire initially...not so much now
4. Miles.....IF he would hire an OC that could develop a QB he would be ranked higher (but LSU was my pick to win the West this year)
5. Petrino...want to put him higher, but this ain't the Big East (BUT, no one outside of Ark. understands how little he had to work with when he arrived here and just how far he has come)
6. Dooley....Not sure why, but I really think he is a good one
7. Richt...things aren't looking good, but I think Bobo is a BIG part of his problems
8. Nutt....good god, i have been dealing with this man for half my life and still can't figure him out
9. Phillips....See #6
10. Spurrier...think he has lost it (pulling his starter on the last drive only reinforces my thoughts)
11. Mullen, could very easily be as high as 6-7, just haven't seen enough to convince me yet
12. Caldwell...funny guy but out of his league
14
Posted on 9/27/10 at 10:45 pm to Head Hog
nice job putting two guys who haven't won an SEC game over Mullen.
Posted on 9/27/10 at 10:45 pm to Head Hog
chiz at 3 will have people going insane
Posted on 9/27/10 at 10:47 pm to Head Hog
Miles could be so much better if he would get out of his own way. LSU has a killer defense and special teams. Recruiting is amazing. This is his 6th year and there is no talent drop off.
But, the OC and QB is atrocious. That will be his undoing and it is such a waste. If LSU had even decent QB play, November 6th against Alabama in Tiger Stadium would be the date everyone was penciling as deciding the SEC. As it is, LSU fans are hoping we finish better than 8-4. Beyond frustrating.
Oh yeah, he is also terrible at clock management. But, objectively, he has done about 2/3 of his job really well. It is the other third that will be his undoing.
But, the OC and QB is atrocious. That will be his undoing and it is such a waste. If LSU had even decent QB play, November 6th against Alabama in Tiger Stadium would be the date everyone was penciling as deciding the SEC. As it is, LSU fans are hoping we finish better than 8-4. Beyond frustrating.
Oh yeah, he is also terrible at clock management. But, objectively, he has done about 2/3 of his job really well. It is the other third that will be his undoing.
Posted on 9/27/10 at 10:48 pm to Head Hog
quote:
3. Chiz.......I laughed at this hire initially...not so much now
ill go ahead and start the poking fun at this, chiz hasn't done anything yet. Miles > Chiz.
Posted on 9/27/10 at 10:51 pm to Head Hog
I don't even know where to start with this list. You must be watching a totally different 4 games than I have on a couple of guys...
Posted on 9/27/10 at 10:51 pm to Head Hog
Saban
Meyer
Petrino
Spurrier
Richt
Miles
Mullen
Nutt
Chizik
Joker
Caldwell
Dooley
Meyer
Petrino
Spurrier
Richt
Miles
Mullen
Nutt
Chizik
Joker
Caldwell
Dooley
Posted on 9/27/10 at 10:55 pm to Head Hog
Miles and Chizik are too high. Mullen is a little too low. Otherwise, I pretty much agree.
Posted on 9/27/10 at 11:10 pm to Head Hog
quote:
6. Dooley....Not sure why, but I really think he is a good one
Also,
A WAC reject is just who we needed. He'll be the biggest failure of them all. I've fricking hated this hick since the day we hired him.
The way he's recruiting he must not realize he's not in Ruston anymore. I swear to God the love he gets on this board from some people drives me crazy. I hate his fricking guts and would dance in the streets if he was fired tomorrow.
This post was edited on 9/27/10 at 11:13 pm
Posted on 9/28/10 at 12:04 am to Head Hog
Saban
Meyer
Petrino
Mullen
Spurrier
Rict
Joker
Nutt
Chizik
Caldwell
Dooley
Miles
Meyer
Petrino
Mullen
Spurrier
Rict
Joker
Nutt
Chizik
Caldwell
Dooley
Miles
This post was edited on 9/28/10 at 12:05 am
Posted on 9/28/10 at 7:25 am to Head Hog
quote:
Meyer......Is he ranked so high because of past success? We find out Saturday
A loss on Saturday to the heavily favored number 1 team in American on the road with the current Heisman winner, the best coach in CFB and with the best OL and WR and 2nd best RB in the game would change your mind???
Posted on 9/28/10 at 7:36 am to Head Hog
quote:
11. Mullen, could very easily be as high as 6-7, just haven't seen enough to convince me yet
You really think that Houston Nutt has done a better coaching job than Dan Mullen in losing to D-1AA Jacksonville State and Vandy at home???? State lost to number 10 Auburn at home by 3 and AT Tiger Stadium AT NIGHT to number 12 LSU. Honestly what do you expect of Mullen? Him to be 4-0 and have blown out LSU and Auburn
This list is full of FAIL!
Posted on 9/28/10 at 9:41 am to Head Hog
quote:
6. Dooley....Not sure why, but I really think he is a good one
7. Richt...things aren't looking good, but I think Bobo is a BIG part of his problems
8. Nutt....good god, i have been dealing with this man for half my life and still can't figure him out
9. Phillips....See #6
10. Spurrier...think he has lost it (pulling his starter on the last drive only reinforces my thoughts)
Dooley has accomplished nothing. Richt and Nutt and Spurrier have all won at least an SEC division championship. Spurrier has won nat champ games. PLURAL.
Your vote for Dooley parallels women voting for handsome candidates for high office.
Spurrier has been pulling QB's for years. Nothing new here.
Posted on 9/28/10 at 11:48 am to Head Hog
quote:
10. Spurrier...think he has lost it (pulling his starter on the last drive only reinforces my thoughts)
Because his starter fumbled twice and he was worried about him hurting himself constantly lowering his head. (HBC explained his decision in an article on GoGamecocks but it's a pay site so no link). His decision was just fine, IMO. FWIW, Shaw played fairly well that last drive.
I'd have to disagree, I'll put SOS at 5-6 at this point. He's WAY better than 10th.
ETA: Gamecock Central article
This post was edited on 9/28/10 at 11:52 am
Posted on 9/28/10 at 12:14 pm to Head Hog
Mullen at 11 is pretty terrible IMO. If you are gonna rank the coaches, rank them by who you would want to run your program.
1. Saban is obviously first
2. After him, in no particular order, Meyer, Mullen, Spurrier,
3. Petrino, Chiz
4. Dooley, Richt, Phillips
5. Nutt, Caldwell, Miles
1. Saban is obviously first
2. After him, in no particular order, Meyer, Mullen, Spurrier,
3. Petrino, Chiz
4. Dooley, Richt, Phillips
5. Nutt, Caldwell, Miles
This post was edited on 9/28/10 at 12:15 pm
Page 1 of 1
Popular
Back to top
Follow SECRant for SEC Football News