Started By
Message
re: Eric Berry shouldn't be 1st Team All-SEC
Posted on 11/20/09 at 5:01 pm to woopiginaustin
Posted on 11/20/09 at 5:01 pm to woopiginaustin
WooPig, you can't equate post season awards with who actually is the "best player" and should be named 1st team all SEC because there are just too many variables that go into what constitutes "1st Team”.
I'm as big of a Mallet Fan as there is (just look at my posts as early as last spring when I saw him first hand) but he shouldn't be named 1st team all SEC. That award should go to Tebow. That doesn't mean that if I were starting a football team from scratch that I wouldn't take Mallet over Tebow because I would but Tebow deserves to be 1st team all SEC this year.
Mallett will be back with the Hogs next year and he will get his shot at being 1st team all SEC then. Your campaign to convince posters that Mallet should be 1st team All SEC is admirable but it's time to move on. It' not going to happen.
I'm as big of a Mallet Fan as there is (just look at my posts as early as last spring when I saw him first hand) but he shouldn't be named 1st team all SEC. That award should go to Tebow. That doesn't mean that if I were starting a football team from scratch that I wouldn't take Mallet over Tebow because I would but Tebow deserves to be 1st team all SEC this year.
Mallett will be back with the Hogs next year and he will get his shot at being 1st team all SEC then. Your campaign to convince posters that Mallet should be 1st team All SEC is admirable but it's time to move on. It' not going to happen.
This post was edited on 11/20/09 at 5:02 pm
1
Posted on 11/20/09 at 5:15 pm to Choctaw Hog
quote:
WooPig, you can't equate post season awards with who actually is the "best player" and should be named 1st team all SEC because there are just too many variables that go into what constitutes "1st Team”.
I'm as big of a Mallet Fan as there is (just look at my posts as early as last spring when I saw him first hand) but he shouldn't be named 1st team all SEC. That award should go to Tebow. That doesn't mean that if I were starting a football team from scratch that I wouldn't take Mallet over Tebow because I would but Tebow deserves to be 1st team all SEC this year.
Well, what exactly makes Tebow 1st Team in your eyes?
We can all agree it's not stats.
If it's off the field feel good stories, do we not honor those who are thugs like Spikes? What if you aren't morally upstanding? Since when do we hand out SEC honors on this?
If it's "leadership", isn't that a tad subjective? I know a whole team of men that call Mallett their leader.
If it's team records, does Eric Berry drop to 3rd team?
This post was edited on 11/20/09 at 5:19 pm
Page 1 of 1
Back to top
Follow SECRant for SEC Football News