re: Picking from the SEC QBs since the 2000s, You have 1 game to win...who's your guy?

quote:

---

Matt Jones.

---

Coked out WR from Jacksonville?

quote:

---

Tebow,

---

41 starts, 6 losses (.854)

quote:

---

Manziel,

---

25 starts, 6 losses (.760)

quote:

---

Matt Jones

---

41 starts, 16 losses (.610)

Cameron Newton, 14 starts, 0 losses (1.000)

quote:

---

You have 1 game to win...who's your guy?

---

Did you misunderstand the question?

Either Andrew hatch or Anthony Jennings....

quote:

---

Manziel was not a good passer. He had all day to throw because his starting OL had 4 guys that went on to be drafted in the 1st round as OTs

---

Have you seen UGA's OL?

quote:

---

When he finally did decide to throw it he basically chucked up prayers that only 6'5" All-Pro freak Mike Evans would be able to come down with

---

This is why I added my other remark in a separate post, mentioning maybe one of the Bama QBs. When I made my first comment, I was just thinking out of the 3 "best QBs" who would I drop in... but yeah, it's not like there is a perfect QB for every offensive style/roster, it's all about tradeoffs. BUT... if I went Manziel, I've got 6'5" Charlie Woerner at TE/Flex End... 6'5" Lawrence Cager transfer WR from Miami who is getting good buzz this summer... 5* Incoming Freshman George Pickens who is known for good hands and body control... I wouldn't feel terrible about our odds of pulling down a lot of those throws.

quote:

---

Tebow had even more to work with.

---

It's not like we're working with a barren roster. He was a great leader. He made players around him better.

quote:

---

And don't give me that shite about "but muh offensive system", Carolina finally brought in a real OC who installed the most complex offense of his career for Cam last year and he thrived passing the ball, and did it all with a bum shoulder, no Olsen, and shite WRs.

---

You're taking this as some slight against Cam. He's 8 fricking years into his NFL career... one would hope that as a professional athlete you continue to grow and develop. But I am assuming the hypothetical is dropping in the player "from their NCAA prime" essentially... not where they got to now. If not, then there is no way I want Manziel on my roster. I'd take Cam or Stafford I guess just based on NFL capabilities?

quote:

---

How in the actual frick would JFF and WWJD have fit better into Georgia's pro style system?

---

As I said neither of them are perfect fits... but it certainly feels weird saying "I'll take AJ McCarron over Cam/JFF/Tebow" doesn't it? So I initially leaned toward ranking the 3 with that caveat. Sorry it got you all up in your feelings about Cam.

quote:

---

As I said neither of them are perfect fits... but it certainly feels weird saying "I'll take AJ McCarron over Cam/JFF/Tebow" doesn't it? So I initially leaned toward ranking the 3 with that caveat. Sorry it got you all up in your feelings about Cam.

---

I love it when a fan asks a question, then if you don't answer the way they want you to they want to argue and call you names. What is the point of him asking a question if he isn't really interested in how other people think?

quote:

---

I love it when a fan asks a question, then if you don't answer the way they want you to they want to argue and call you names. What is the point of him asking a question if he isn't really interested in how other people think?

---

I'm perhaps more interested in the "look at all the talent they had around them" bit as though Cam had none... I mean, if I'm going QBs that performed well despite not much talent around them, Andre Woodson at Kentucky threw 40 damn TDs in a season with not particularly great talent around him... Seems like I should maybe give him a look.