Started By
Message
Manziel, Winston, Newton, Mayfield, tebow
Posted on 2/6/18 at 2:58 pm
Posted on 2/6/18 at 2:58 pm
How do you rank these 5 heisman winners? I say 1. Cam
2. JF
3. Mayfield
4. Tebow
5. Winston
Any disagreement? This is purely based off college performance
2. JF
3. Mayfield
4. Tebow
5. Winston
Any disagreement? This is purely based off college performance
This post was edited on 2/6/18 at 2:59 pm
26
Posted on 2/6/18 at 2:59 pm to Hawgnsincebirth55
1. manziel
2-5. who gives a frick
2-5. who gives a frick
Posted on 2/6/18 at 3:00 pm to WestCoastAg
winston above mayfield
Winston lost 1 game, right?
Winston lost 1 game, right?
Posted on 2/6/18 at 3:00 pm to Hawgnsincebirth55
Manziel too high
Figuratively and literally
Figuratively and literally
Posted on 2/6/18 at 3:00 pm to Hawgnsincebirth55
I'll do at their peak.
JFF
Cam
Tebow
Winston
Mayfield
JFF
Cam
Tebow
Winston
Mayfield
Posted on 2/6/18 at 3:00 pm to Hawgnsincebirth55
1. Manziel
Others
Others
Posted on 2/6/18 at 3:01 pm to Hawgnsincebirth55
1. Tebow
2. Cam
3. Winston
4. Mayfield
5. JF
Tebow did more than anyone. End of story.
2. Cam
3. Winston
4. Mayfield
5. JF
Tebow did more than anyone. End of story.
Posted on 2/6/18 at 3:02 pm to Hawgnsincebirth55
Posted on 2/6/18 at 3:08 pm to Hawgnsincebirth55
Johnny football and Tebow both lost to Alabama so they are already below Cam and Winston and mayfield at least.
Posted on 2/6/18 at 3:20 pm to FourThreeForty
Tebow also beat Bama for the SEC title in 2008. Cam wasn't good enough to beat out John Brantley and Winston was gifted a title by Auburn.
Posted on 2/6/18 at 3:25 pm to Hawgnsincebirth55
Cam, Tebow, Winston, JF, Mayfield. In that order. Natty's aren't the whole picture but they do count for something.
JF and Mayfield never won a meaningful game but were great players. Mayfield never beat good teams consistently. Still, if he played on a team that played defense, he could have done much better. JF was really only "great" for one season.
Winston took a full half to get warmed up and threw way too many interceptions but he did come back against a decent Auburn team.
Tebow or Cam could be #1 but I would take Cam at the top. He was truly a giant among boys. He was pretty much unstoppable. Tebow could will a win but was stoppable at times.
JF and Mayfield never won a meaningful game but were great players. Mayfield never beat good teams consistently. Still, if he played on a team that played defense, he could have done much better. JF was really only "great" for one season.
Winston took a full half to get warmed up and threw way too many interceptions but he did come back against a decent Auburn team.
Tebow or Cam could be #1 but I would take Cam at the top. He was truly a giant among boys. He was pretty much unstoppable. Tebow could will a win but was stoppable at times.
Posted on 2/6/18 at 3:25 pm to ColoBama
quote:
JF was really only "great" for one season.
Posted on 2/6/18 at 3:26 pm to Hawgnsincebirth55
Cam
HUGE GAP
Winston
Tebow
JF
Mayfield
HUGE GAP
Winston
Tebow
JF
Mayfield
Posted on 2/6/18 at 3:28 pm to ColoBama
quote:
JF was really only "great" for one season.
Yeah because 4800 yards of total offense and 47 TDs while playing in the SEC isn’t that hard right?
Posted on 2/6/18 at 3:28 pm to craigbiggio
quote:
Cam
HUGE GAP
Can't disagree with that.
Posted on 2/6/18 at 3:30 pm to 1BamaRTR
quote:
Yeah because 4800 yards of total offense and 47 TDs while playing in the SEC isn’t that hard right?
Not that impressed with him except for his first season.
Posted on 2/6/18 at 3:32 pm to craigbiggio
Huge Gap?
Let's just see the awards Tebow won.
2× BCS national champion (2006, 2008)
2× SEC champion (2006, 2008)
2× SEC Player of the Year (2008, 2009)
Manning Award (2008)
2× Maxwell Award (2007, 2008)
Heisman Trophy (2007)
Davey O'Brien Award (2007)[1]
AP Player of the Year (2007)[2]
Sporting News Player of the Year (2007)
2× First-team All-American (2007, 2008)
Second-team All-American (2009)
3× First-team All-SEC (2007–2009)
He also got royally screwed in 2008 for the Heisman. He had the most first place votes, but the mid western voters didn't
put him on the ballot to make sure Bradford or Mccoy won. Was the biggest Heisman crime of the century.
No one dominated CFB like Tebow. He had the news cycle, the eyes, and he was basically his own brand. Some of that of course was his virgin boy christian stuff of course, but he proved it every week despite a weird throwing motion and lacking natural passing ability.
Cam is a better pro QB yes. But the only comparable college QB to Tebow in the last fifty years is Tommy Frazier. He is the ONLY QB who had as big of an impact as Tebow.
Let's just see the awards Tebow won.
2× BCS national champion (2006, 2008)
2× SEC champion (2006, 2008)
2× SEC Player of the Year (2008, 2009)
Manning Award (2008)
2× Maxwell Award (2007, 2008)
Heisman Trophy (2007)
Davey O'Brien Award (2007)[1]
AP Player of the Year (2007)[2]
Sporting News Player of the Year (2007)
2× First-team All-American (2007, 2008)
Second-team All-American (2009)
3× First-team All-SEC (2007–2009)
He also got royally screwed in 2008 for the Heisman. He had the most first place votes, but the mid western voters didn't
put him on the ballot to make sure Bradford or Mccoy won. Was the biggest Heisman crime of the century.
No one dominated CFB like Tebow. He had the news cycle, the eyes, and he was basically his own brand. Some of that of course was his virgin boy christian stuff of course, but he proved it every week despite a weird throwing motion and lacking natural passing ability.
Cam is a better pro QB yes. But the only comparable college QB to Tebow in the last fifty years is Tommy Frazier. He is the ONLY QB who had as big of an impact as Tebow.
This post was edited on 2/6/18 at 3:35 pm
Posted on 2/6/18 at 3:35 pm to ColoBama
quote:
4800 yards of total offense and 47 TDs
quote:this place i swear
Not that impressed with him
Posted on 2/6/18 at 3:36 pm to Hawgnsincebirth55
Tebow
Winston*
Cam
Mayfield
Manziel
*college success only. Winston went to the playoff twice, cam really only had the one year
Winston*
Cam
Mayfield
Manziel
*college success only. Winston went to the playoff twice, cam really only had the one year
Posted on 2/6/18 at 3:36 pm to Gatorbait2008
Lol Cam won all of those awards in one shot. He would have won them all again if he didn't leave after his junior year. Tebow stayed in college because he knew he would suck in the NFL and was surrounded by superior talent.
This is stupid. Look at Auburn before and after Cam.
He won a national title with GENE CHIZIK as his coach.
And went undefeated, something Tebow never did
quote:
But the only comparable college QB to Tebow in the last fifty years is Tommy Frazier. He is the ONLY QB who had as big of an impact as Tebow.
This is stupid. Look at Auburn before and after Cam.
He won a national title with GENE CHIZIK as his coach.
And went undefeated, something Tebow never did
This post was edited on 2/6/18 at 3:38 pm
Page 1 of 4
Popular
Back to top
Follow SECRant for SEC Football News