Started By
Message
re: BAMA football stuff - Ranking opposing QB's Bama is facing edition
Posted on 4/22/12 at 3:01 pm to ohiovol
Posted on 4/22/12 at 3:01 pm to ohiovol
guess what, Craig Krenzel, who yall are saying is an average QB, beat the mighty Miami Hurricanes who were absolutely stacked on both sides of the ball, he's better than you are giving him credit for.
also, he didnt win the BCS MVP because of his 7-21 passing effort with 2 ints. He won because he had 19 carries for 81 yards and 2 rushing TDs.
also, he didnt win the BCS MVP because of his 7-21 passing effort with 2 ints. He won because he had 19 carries for 81 yards and 2 rushing TDs.
This post was edited on 4/22/12 at 3:02 pm
2
Posted on 4/22/12 at 3:02 pm to Rickdaddy4188
quote:
188 yards per game 16TD in 14 games. Those are game manager numbers. Not top 3 SEC QBs. Deal with it.
DING DING DING
WE HAVE A WINNER
Rickdaddy does have a point. A good QB would have to be able to make longer passes like smash routes rather than just screen passes. There is no way a good coach would ever put the game plan on the shoulders of an average game manager QB when they were facing one of the best defenses in the nation in the championship game.
By all of Rickdaddy's "Deal with it" logic, AJ is nothing more than a game manager so there is no way that the LSU defense was worth a damn if that average QB could pick them apart like he did.
Posted on 4/22/12 at 3:03 pm to ALcapone
quote:
guess what, Craig Krenzel, who yall are saying is an average QB, beat the mighty Miami Hurricanes who were absolutely stacked on both sides of the ball, he's better than you are giving him credit for. also, he didnt win the BCS MVP because of his 7-21 passing effort with 2 ints. He won because he had 19 carries for 81 yards and 2 rushing TDs.
He is a qb who had a very avg game. You said avg qb don't win MVP awards. You have been weighed and measured and have been found wanting!
This post was edited on 4/22/12 at 3:12 pm
Posted on 4/22/12 at 3:08 pm to T Rey WI
So you think AJ mcarron is a top 3 qb? His stats don't say that. Sooner or later you are what your stats say you are !
Posted on 4/22/12 at 3:09 pm to ALcapone
quote:
also, he didnt win the BCS MVP because of his 7-21 passing effort with 2 ints. He won because he had 19 carries for 81 yards and 2 rushing TDs.
Who cares why he won it? He was, at best, an average quarterback during that season. There's no reason to argue otherwise just to fit your argument for McCarron.
Posted on 4/22/12 at 3:09 pm to Rickdaddy4188
I was simply in agreement with you that LSU's defense must suck. 
Posted on 4/22/12 at 3:10 pm to T Rey WI
Did you not see his game on nov 5th? Less than 50% completions and 120 yards of passing that wasn't swing passes.
Also he played well on jan9th. I've never said he wasn't good. Just that he is a game manager. Why is that such a slap in the face to you gunts? He has done everything asked of him.
Also he played well on jan9th. I've never said he wasn't good. Just that he is a game manager. Why is that such a slap in the face to you gunts? He has done everything asked of him.
Posted on 4/22/12 at 3:11 pm to T Rey WI
AJ had a very good year as a 1st year starter. He showed later in the year potential to be much more. Attempting to say he IS a top QB has yet to be proven. I hope he proves that to be the case this year but time will tell.
Posted on 4/22/12 at 3:13 pm to Rickdaddy4188
I was just having fun using your own arguments to poke at you 
Posted on 4/22/12 at 3:16 pm to T Rey WI
quote:
He showed later in the year potential to be much more.
In the bowl game the receivers had to make some acrobatic catches. But the important thing is he placed the ball where either his guy caught it or it was incomplete...not intercepted. This is important to Saban and is why I think the O will open it up a bit more in 2012.
Posted on 4/22/12 at 3:17 pm to TTsTowel
quote:
He was, at best, an average quarterback during that season. There's no reason to argue otherwise just to fit your argument for McCarron
he was better than average based on his accomplishments. yall can sit here and say oh he was average, but he's sitting at home with a ring and an MVP award that say differently.
Posted on 4/22/12 at 3:19 pm to ALcapone
We should just accept the fact that McCarron can't beat a team when it's put on his shoulders. Oh, wait...
Meanwhile, the wannabe Roethlisberger has never started a SEC game.
Meanwhile, the wannabe Roethlisberger has never started a SEC game.
Posted on 4/22/12 at 3:19 pm to ALcapone
quote:
yall can sit here and say oh he was average
It's not 'ya'll', it's his actual performance through the year. I think it's agreed he stepped up in bowl game.
Posted on 4/22/12 at 3:20 pm to ALcapone
quote:
he was better than average based on his accomplishments. yall can sit here and say oh he was average, but he's sitting at home with a ring and an MVP award that say differently.
Neiko Thorpe won MVP in some games and has a ring. What's your point?
Posted on 4/22/12 at 3:21 pm to dbt_Geaux_Tigers_196
quote:
I think it's agreed he stepped up in bowl game.
In truth, he stepped his play up a little each week after the 1st LSU game. The last step was just the biggest one with more time between games to prep.
Posted on 4/22/12 at 3:26 pm to TTsTowel
quote:
Neiko Thorpe won MVP in some games and has a ring. What's your point?
is Thorpe a QB of a BCS Championship winning team?
My point is Krenzel has earned the accolades that prove him to be better than average and for you to sit back and dismiss his accomplishments because you think it proves that AJ McCarron is just average is stupid.
Posted on 4/22/12 at 3:26 pm to T Rey WI
quote:
quote:
I think it's agreed he stepped up in bowl game.
In truth, he stepped his play up a little each week after the 1st LSU game. The last step was just the biggest one with more time between games to prep.
MSU (163 yds) , GSU (190 yds) and AU (184 yds)?
Posted on 4/22/12 at 3:26 pm to T Rey WI
Yes LSU's defense sucked because a qb with a month to prepare had a decent game against us. Hell Geno Smith must be all world if Mcarron is great. I guess his Nov.5th game is just erased from your memory. Damn you gunts have shut out the fact that you went 1-1 against LSU last year.
Posted on 4/22/12 at 3:28 pm to Alahunter
Meh, let the fapfest continue. To the OP, for a way too early pick, I'd say Wilson, Bray then Robinson, taking into account known quantities only.
This post was edited on 4/22/12 at 3:29 pm
Posted on 4/22/12 at 3:28 pm to T Rey WI
quote:
AJ had a very good year as a 1st year starter. He showed later in the year potential to be much more. Attempting to say he IS a top QB has yet to be proven. I hope he proves that to be the case this year but time will tell.
He had an avg year. Not good not bad. Avg 16tds in 14 games isn't good, it's meh. Had any other teams' qb's put up the exact same stats as AJ , you Bama fans would be laughing at the poster who said the qb was top 3.
Page 6 of 15
Popular
Back to top
Follow SECRant for SEC Football News