Alabama WRs or LSU WRs who you got?

you'd be splitting hairs to say who, collectively, is better overall. Alabama has the best of the two with Julio. also wouldn't say Alabama is any more top heavy than LSU. Beckham is obviously hurt this year, but he, Landry, and Jefferson are just as top heavy as Julio, Ridley, and Cooper IMO.

Note: I'd also include Michael Clayton if we're going as far back as Josh Reed, possibly Rueben Randle as well. Devery Henderson is a pretty glaring omission. Trindon Holliday also doesn't belong. All he ever did in the NFL was return punts and kicks.

LSU

Chase puts them over the top

You are truly splitting hairs.

Several of those guys never realized their college potential due to inconsistent QB play at LSU.

All of the WR talent for Bama and lsu back when neither team used them properly is such a facepalm looking back at it

Bama fans do it just as much

This board in its entirety is incredibly hypocritical

We should probably just judge them on their head-to-head records and number of championships while in college.

Well Bama is the only team that compares to LSU in talent at WR and player production. And vice versa.

But yet that’s obsessed even though it’s a board for fans to discuss. Smh.

We tested this last year...

Plus Alabama had Waddle

Give me Chase, Jefferson, and Marshall all day every day and twice on Sundays

quote:

---

Note: I'd also include Michael Clayton if we're going as far back as Josh Reed, possibly Rueben Randle as well. Devery Henderson is a pretty glaring omission. Trindon Holliday also doesn't belong. All he ever did in the NFL was return punts and kicks.

---

If going back that far, need to include Eddie Kennison too.

I think Julio being what he's been in the NFL likely tilts it to Bama. he's the only lock HOF of the bunch on either side and has so many NFL records to his credit. that said, both lists are impressive.