Which WR group is better?

2012, but only because they delivered over 13 games.

2015 has 8 more games to change my vote.

Better than Evans??? No way

Would have liked to seen Kirk play with JF.

Very tough.

Evans > Reynolds

Kennedy > speedy (As of right this minute in terms of production. I think speedy has more talent but he has to prove it over his career)

Swope < Kirk (swope was a damn consistent 3rd down target for us but Kirk is something special)

EZ > RSJ ( I realize these are two different types of receivers playing two different positions but in trying to compare starter to starters. If RSJ starts playing more games like the Miss State game he could pass up EZ)

Walker, Jackson, Askew = Pope, Ratley, Davis

So long story short, idk. That's a hard question. I'd go 2012 right now but this 15 team could be better. Need to see more games

You have EZ (26/485/7) way too low


And derel (8/85/0) way too high.

Speedy's too low also, but he needs to be on the field more

quote:

---

Evans > Reynolds

Kennedy > speedy

Swope < Kirk

EZ > RSJ

Walker, Jackson, Askew = Pope, Ratley, Davis

---

The biggest difference in 2012 vs. now is that the best WR plays a different WR position. In 2012 Evans was our best, Kirk is our best now. They do completely different things.

Evans was a superbeast whereas Kirk is the kwisatz haderach. That's a wash.

Kennedy was damn solid. Speedy is worthless. Advantage 2012.

EZ became a major asset. RSJ is on his way. advantage 2012, BUT, RSJ was playing MUCH better vs. State before getting kicked out. However, his Achilles heel so far as ever being a major weapon for us is that he absolutely cannot get YAC under any circumstance. If all the defenders simultaneously had heart attacks and died when he caught the ball, RSJ would still trip and fall down right where he caught it. I hope the trainers keep an epi pin on the sidelines, because the guy is so allergic to YAC that if he ever gains a yard after the catch he might go into anaphylactic shock.

Also - just a general comment - but if we are going to compare individual WRs, we should compare them to their position.

The question is not which wr has the most talent, it's which group is better. We lacked depth in one position last year and we played a walk on in that spot as a result.

Z - Evans vs Noil

X - EZ? and Walker vs. Reynolds / Nacho

H - Kirk / Tabuyo vs Holmes/Swope?

Y - Kennedy/Gonzalez vs RSJ/Holmes

Not sure about these position alignments did this on bad memory

quote:

---

I have no idea why everyone is writing off speedy.

---

He's either been "injured" or in the dog house for issues related to generally having a bad attitude since he got here. The times he has played he's been utterly "meh".

Kirk Muad'Dib is everything Speedy was supposed to be though, so we're 1 for 2 in the past 2 years on supposedly god-like WR recruits, which is actually pretty good!

quote:

---

RSJ reminds me of Marqise Lee in that he seems to always catch the ball with his body even when he doesn't have to.

---

Easy to spot the natural receivers by how they catch the ball.

Evans, Kirk, Josh, Malcome, speedy, those guys are true receivers.

Guys like Swope and RSJ just happen to be at the WR position than any other spot on the field, so they're out there doing their best. Swope turned into a beast by the time he left, hope RSJ can do the same.