Started By
Message
Which system is best?
Posted on 11/26/16 at 9:03 pm
Posted on 11/26/16 at 9:03 pm
1. One National Championship game
2. 4 team playoff determined by committee
3. 4 team playoff determined by committee (requirement to be Conf Champ)
4. 6 team playoff. 5 P5 Conf champs and a G5 Conf Champ. Top 2 get bye.
5. 8 team playoff. 5 P5 Conf Champs, G5 Conf champ, 2 next highest ranked teams.
Personally, #3 is the ideal option.
2. 4 team playoff determined by committee
3. 4 team playoff determined by committee (requirement to be Conf Champ)
4. 6 team playoff. 5 P5 Conf champs and a G5 Conf Champ. Top 2 get bye.
5. 8 team playoff. 5 P5 Conf Champs, G5 Conf champ, 2 next highest ranked teams.
Personally, #3 is the ideal option.
9
Posted on 11/26/16 at 9:04 pm to Weagle25
8 team playoff chosen by the BCS system
Posted on 11/26/16 at 9:05 pm to Weagle25
Give me a 4 team playoff determined by the BCS. frick a committee and their arbitrary, emotional response to games.
Posted on 11/26/16 at 9:06 pm to Tuscaloosa
quote:
their arbitrary, emotional response to games.
What an accurate description of the BCS
Posted on 11/26/16 at 9:07 pm to Weagle25
4 team playoff determined by BCS
Posted on 11/26/16 at 9:07 pm to Tuscaloosa
quote:This, except I like the 8 team playoff...although you would need to subtract unnecessary games against teams like Alabama A&M so these kids weren't exposed to too much of a beating so young.
Give me a 4 team playoff determined by the BCS. frick a committee and their arbitrary, emotional response to games.
Posted on 11/26/16 at 9:08 pm to Weagle25
In option 3 if requirement is conference champ then why the frick do you need a committee
Posted on 11/26/16 at 9:08 pm to Weagle25
Id be ok with an 8 team playoff with games on campuses except for the championship
Posted on 11/26/16 at 9:09 pm to Iron Lion
quote:
In option 3 if requirement is conference champ then why the frick do you need a committee
Because there's more than 4 conferences
Posted on 11/26/16 at 9:10 pm to Weagle25
I hate the conf champion argument when a conf champ will be left out. The only way I could support a requirement to be a conf champ is a power five and one at large.
At which point is like to see the sec do away with divisions. Schedule 2 OOC games. One power five team and a rent a win from your own state. The other games would be against conf teams.
At which point is like to see the sec do away with divisions. Schedule 2 OOC games. One power five team and a rent a win from your own state. The other games would be against conf teams.
Posted on 11/26/16 at 9:10 pm to Tuscaloosa
IMO the Big 12 just needs to dissolve. I think most people realize it's just a matter of time before it does.
Now you have 4 power conferences. You take the 4 champions. They get seeded 1-4. Then you take the next best 4 schools in the BCS.
Now you have 4 power conferences. You take the 4 champions. They get seeded 1-4. Then you take the next best 4 schools in the BCS.
Posted on 11/26/16 at 9:12 pm to Weagle25
8 team playoff, chosen by me, based solely on uniforms.
Posted on 11/26/16 at 9:12 pm to Weagle25
6 team playoff.
Posted on 11/26/16 at 9:13 pm to ford1911
If it goes to 8 teams, I think it would water down the importance of the regular season.
College football games matter every week, which makes it the best regular season in sports.
College football games matter every week, which makes it the best regular season in sports.
Posted on 11/26/16 at 9:13 pm to labamafan
Of course you hate it, that's the reason you guys won the 2011 natty. Because apparently our regular season didn't matter. We should've played like OK state or some bullshite team and went home with that but..... les started JJ and we got fricked
Posted on 11/26/16 at 9:13 pm to labamafan
Of course you hate it, that's the reason you guys won the 2011 natty. Because apparently our regular season didn't matter. We should've played like OK state or some bullshite team and went home with that but..... les started JJ and we got fricked
Posted on 11/26/16 at 9:18 pm to Weagle25
quote:
What an accurate description of the BCS
BCS was a computer based system that used a very specific list of criteria. It is literally the polar opposite of having a committee... who basically just make up whatever arbitrary criteria they want on any given week, and we never know what those criteria are.
Posted on 11/26/16 at 9:19 pm to MagillaGuerilla
Marshall 
Posted on 11/26/16 at 9:19 pm to Tuscaloosa
Has the committee gotten it wrong yet? I can't recall.
Posted on 11/26/16 at 9:22 pm to Tuscaloosa
quote:
BCS was a computer based system
2/3 of the system was not computer based and was based on less solid criteria than the committee uses
This post was edited on 11/26/16 at 9:24 pm
Page 1 of 2
Popular
Back to top
Follow SECRant for SEC Football News