Started By
Message
SB Nation uses facts and figures to figure out who is Bust U?
Posted on 4/28/16 at 12:17 pm
Posted on 4/28/16 at 12:17 pm
Who is Bust U?
Following criteria are used (since 1990)
1. % of 1st Round Picks that played 4+ Seasons
2. % of 1st Round Picks that were Starters 3+ Seasons
3. % of 1st Round Picks that made a Pro Bowl
SEC Rankings - #1 Criteria
#1 - Auburn (100%, 14/14)
#1 - Ole Miss (100%, 10/10)
#1 - Missouri (100%, 8/8)
#1 - South Carolina (100%, 8/8)
#1 - Arkansas (100%, 7/7)
#1 - Mississippi State (100%, 4/4)
#1 - Kentucky (100%, 3/3)
#1 - Vanderbilt (100%, 2/2)
#9 - Alabama (96%, 25/26)
#9 - Tennessee (96%, 25/26)
#11 - LSU (95%, 19/20)
#12 - Texas A&M (94%, 16/17)
#13 - Florida (89%, 25/28)
#14 - Georgia (85%, 18/21)
SEC Rankings - #2 Criteria
#1 - Vanderbilt (100%, 2/2)
#2 - Alabama (92%, 24/26)
#3 - Auburn (86%, 12/14)
#4 - Ole Miss (80%, 8/10)
#5 - Mississippi State (75%, 3/4)
#5 - LSU (75%, 15/20)
#7 - Georgia (71%, 15/21)
#8 - Tennessee (69%, 18/26)
#9 - Kentucky (67%, 2/3)
#10 - Texas A&M (65%, 11/17)
#11 - Florida (64%, 18/28)
#12 - Missouri (63%, 5/8)
#12 - South Carolina (63%, 5/8)
#14 - Arkansas (57%, 4/7)
SEC Rankings - #3 Criteria
#1 - Mississippi State (75%, 3/4)
#2 - Vanderbilt (50%, 1/2)
#2 - Georgia (43%, 9/21)
#2 - Auburn (43%, 6/14)
#5 - Ole Miss (40%, 4/10)
#6 - Tennessee (38%, 10/26)
#6 - Missouri (38%, 3/8)
#8 - Florida (36%, 10/28)
#9 - LSU (35%, 7/20)
#10 - Alabama (27%, 7/26)
#11 - South Carolina (25%, 2/8)
#12 - Texas A&M (24%, 4/17)
#13 - Arkansas (14%, 1/7)
#14 - Kentucky (0%)
FINAL ANALYSIS - WHICH TEAMS PLAYERS ARE SUCCESSFUL AT HIGHEST RATE SINCE 1990? (Average %)
1. Vanderbilt - 83%
2. Mississippi St - 83%
3. Auburn - 76%
4. Ole Miss - 73%
5. Alabama - 72%
6. LSU - 68%
6. Tennessee - 68%
8. Missouri - 67%
9. Georgia - 66%
10. Florida - 63%
10. South Carolina - 63%
12. Texas A&M - 61%
13. Arkansas - 57%
14. Kentucky - 56%
Total 1st Round Picks since 1990
1. Florida - 28
2. Alabama - 26
2. Tennessee - 26
4. Georgia - 21
5. LSU - 20
6. Texas A&M - 17
7. Auburn - 14
8. Ole Miss - 10
9. Missouri - 8
9. South Carolina - 8
11. Arkansas - 7
12. Mississippi State - 4
13. Kentucky - 3
14. Vanderbilt - 2
Following criteria are used (since 1990)
1. % of 1st Round Picks that played 4+ Seasons
2. % of 1st Round Picks that were Starters 3+ Seasons
3. % of 1st Round Picks that made a Pro Bowl
SEC Rankings - #1 Criteria
#1 - Auburn (100%, 14/14)
#1 - Ole Miss (100%, 10/10)
#1 - Missouri (100%, 8/8)
#1 - South Carolina (100%, 8/8)
#1 - Arkansas (100%, 7/7)
#1 - Mississippi State (100%, 4/4)
#1 - Kentucky (100%, 3/3)
#1 - Vanderbilt (100%, 2/2)
#9 - Alabama (96%, 25/26)
#9 - Tennessee (96%, 25/26)
#11 - LSU (95%, 19/20)
#12 - Texas A&M (94%, 16/17)
#13 - Florida (89%, 25/28)
#14 - Georgia (85%, 18/21)
SEC Rankings - #2 Criteria
#1 - Vanderbilt (100%, 2/2)
#2 - Alabama (92%, 24/26)
#3 - Auburn (86%, 12/14)
#4 - Ole Miss (80%, 8/10)
#5 - Mississippi State (75%, 3/4)
#5 - LSU (75%, 15/20)
#7 - Georgia (71%, 15/21)
#8 - Tennessee (69%, 18/26)
#9 - Kentucky (67%, 2/3)
#10 - Texas A&M (65%, 11/17)
#11 - Florida (64%, 18/28)
#12 - Missouri (63%, 5/8)
#12 - South Carolina (63%, 5/8)
#14 - Arkansas (57%, 4/7)
SEC Rankings - #3 Criteria
#1 - Mississippi State (75%, 3/4)
#2 - Vanderbilt (50%, 1/2)
#2 - Georgia (43%, 9/21)
#2 - Auburn (43%, 6/14)
#5 - Ole Miss (40%, 4/10)
#6 - Tennessee (38%, 10/26)
#6 - Missouri (38%, 3/8)
#8 - Florida (36%, 10/28)
#9 - LSU (35%, 7/20)
#10 - Alabama (27%, 7/26)
#11 - South Carolina (25%, 2/8)
#12 - Texas A&M (24%, 4/17)
#13 - Arkansas (14%, 1/7)
#14 - Kentucky (0%)
FINAL ANALYSIS - WHICH TEAMS PLAYERS ARE SUCCESSFUL AT HIGHEST RATE SINCE 1990? (Average %)
1. Vanderbilt - 83%
2. Mississippi St - 83%
3. Auburn - 76%
4. Ole Miss - 73%
5. Alabama - 72%
6. LSU - 68%
6. Tennessee - 68%
8. Missouri - 67%
9. Georgia - 66%
10. Florida - 63%
10. South Carolina - 63%
12. Texas A&M - 61%
13. Arkansas - 57%
14. Kentucky - 56%
Total 1st Round Picks since 1990
1. Florida - 28
2. Alabama - 26
2. Tennessee - 26
4. Georgia - 21
5. LSU - 20
6. Texas A&M - 17
7. Auburn - 14
8. Ole Miss - 10
9. Missouri - 8
9. South Carolina - 8
11. Arkansas - 7
12. Mississippi State - 4
13. Kentucky - 3
14. Vanderbilt - 2
This post was edited on 4/28/16 at 12:44 pm
11
Posted on 4/28/16 at 12:23 pm to SummerOfGeorge
Great selling tool for UF imo.
Posted on 4/28/16 at 12:24 pm to SummerOfGeorge
1. Auburn (63)
2. Tennessee (46)
3. Alabama (45)
4. LSU (40)
5. Georgia (36)
6. Florida (24)
7. Texas A&M (21)
2. Tennessee (46)
3. Alabama (45)
4. LSU (40)
5. Georgia (36)
6. Florida (24)
7. Texas A&M (21)
Posted on 4/28/16 at 12:25 pm to SummerOfGeorge
quote:No hate, it's a ranking system that has concrete criteria. And we do have a lot of subpar athletes in the NFL so not going to disagree with it.
Seems pretty clear at this point that Florida is Bust U in the SEC.
Posted on 4/28/16 at 12:26 pm to SummerOfGeorge
quote:
1. Auburn (63)
2. Tennessee (46)
3. Alabama (45)
4. LSU (40)
5. Georgia (36)
6. Florida (24)
Big 6 bros
Posted on 4/28/16 at 12:28 pm to SummerOfGeorge
How do we have 0% in the third criteria?
Patrick Willis and Eli were both 1st round picks that made the pro bowl
ETA: and Deuce Mcallister
Patrick Willis and Eli were both 1st round picks that made the pro bowl
ETA: and Deuce Mcallister
This post was edited on 4/28/16 at 12:32 pm
Posted on 4/28/16 at 12:28 pm to SummerOfGeorge
AU the new underachieverU?
Posted on 4/28/16 at 12:29 pm to SummerOfGeorge
SC's Jonathan Joseph was a 1st Rd pick AND made the Pro Bowl....list is wrong.
SC's DE Jon Abraham was dradted in the 1st AND made the Pro Bowl....list and SB Nation have shite research
SC's DE Jon Abraham was dradted in the 1st AND made the Pro Bowl....list and SB Nation have shite research
This post was edited on 4/28/16 at 12:32 pm
Posted on 4/28/16 at 12:31 pm to CockInYourEar
Chill bros - for some reason the table is only showing 25 teams in that last grouping.
Posted on 4/28/16 at 12:41 pm to SummerOfGeorge
Not last. 
Posted on 4/28/16 at 12:48 pm to Korin
Alabama, LSU and Tennessee are the only programs that are in the Top 6 in both volume of 1st round picks and production % of those picks.
Kentucky, Arkansas and South Carolina all in the Bottom 10 of both.
Kentucky, Arkansas and South Carolina all in the Bottom 10 of both.
This post was edited on 4/28/16 at 12:49 pm
Posted on 4/28/16 at 12:49 pm to SummerOfGeorge
Not that it matters, but Mizzou has had 4/8 make a Pro Bowl, not 3/8.
1) Justin Smith
2) Jeremy Maclin
3) Aldon Smith
4) Sheldon Richardson
Pro Bowls are a dumb criteria though- All-Pro would be better.
1) Justin Smith
2) Jeremy Maclin
3) Aldon Smith
4) Sheldon Richardson
Pro Bowls are a dumb criteria though- All-Pro would be better.
Posted on 4/28/16 at 1:34 pm to SummerOfGeorge
It is interesting, but doesn't take into account that when one team has 13 players drafted in 1st round, and another has 26, then the team with 26 is twice as likely to have a player not meet one of the criterion.
Someone wishing to do a true analysis would/should factor in a probability component into the equation.
Someone wishing to do a true analysis would/should factor in a probability component into the equation.
Posted on 4/28/16 at 1:36 pm to SummerOfGeorge
Why start at 1990?
The year before, 1989, Bama had one of the greatest players drafted in 1st round and he was a 9 time pro bowler.... Derrick Thomas.
The year before, 1989, Bama had one of the greatest players drafted in 1st round and he was a 9 time pro bowler.... Derrick Thomas.
Posted on 4/28/16 at 1:59 pm to jatebe
quote:
Why start at 1990?
Good question. I was going to say b/c it looks at 25 draft classes, but it is actually 26, so even that doesn't make sense.
Posted on 4/28/16 at 2:02 pm to jatebe
quote:
Why start at 1990? The year before, 1989, Bama had one of the greatest players drafted in 1st round and he was a 9 time pro bowler.... Derrick Thomas.
No clue
Page 1 of 1
Popular
Back to top
Follow SECRant for SEC Football News