Started By
Message
re: Peyton Manning Appreciation Thread
Posted on 2/8/16 at 2:48 am to TheDarrell McSteal
Posted on 2/8/16 at 2:48 am to TheDarrell McSteal
He was unbelievably bad tonight. Denver's defense was heroic.
1
Posted on 2/8/16 at 4:37 am to TheDarrell McSteal
No way is he the GOAT, but he deserves respect. However, that could have just as easily been Osweiler's 1st Super Bowl win. Peyton was solid for many years though. It's a great way to go out for him.
Posted on 2/8/16 at 11:52 am to Robert Goulet
quote:
He has two Super Bowl wins. What exactly is your argument?
Wait, I thought teams won Super Bowls? At least show some consistency.
Posted on 2/8/16 at 12:14 pm to AlabamaAlum07
quote:
Wait, I thought teams won Super Bowls? At least show some consistency
Are you kidding me>? You are wildly inconsistent with your argument
Posted on 2/8/16 at 12:48 pm to VFL1800FPD
Is winning the Super Bowl a team accomplishment?
Posted on 2/8/16 at 12:58 pm to AlabamaAlum07
I'm not even sure what your argument is. Manning has team and individual accomplishments. He has the most passing yards and touchdowns in history and 5 MVPs (individual). He has the most wins in history, 4 super bowl apps with 4 coaches, and won the superbowl with 2 different teams. If you're talking postseason, Brady hasn't beaten him in the playoffs in 11 years and Manning is 3-1 vs Brady Championship games.
Is your only argument that he didn't play well in a couple super bowls?
Is your only argument that he didn't play well in a couple super bowls?
Posted on 2/8/16 at 1:11 pm to AlabamaAlum07
Apparently most of you never watched Joe Montana play. He is the GOAT of all time.
That said, glad Peyton won it and can ride off in the sunset.
That said, glad Peyton won it and can ride off in the sunset.
Posted on 2/8/16 at 1:15 pm to VFL1800FPD
quote:
I'm not even sure what your argument is. Manning has team and individual accomplishments. He has the most passing yards and touchdowns in history and 5 MVPs (individual). He has the most wins in history, 4 super bowl apps with 4 coaches, and won the superbowl with 2 different teams. If you're talking postseason, Brady hasn't beaten him in the playoffs in 11 years and Manning is 3-1 vs Brady Championship games.
Is your only argument that he didn't play well in a couple super bowls?
None of this answers the question.
Posted on 2/8/16 at 1:15 pm to DaveyDownerDawg
quote:
Apparently most of you never watched Joe Montana play. He is the GOAT of all time.
That said, glad Peyton won it and can ride off in the sunset.
Well duh, Montana is obviously #1.
Posted on 2/8/16 at 1:18 pm to AlabamaAlum07
quote:
None of this answers the question.
1st off, let me say I think Manning is arguably in the top 5 of all time. #1 of a list like that is so subjective. So don't think i'm here trying to say Manning is the undisposed GOAT.
Super bowl is obviously a team accomplishment. But did you miss the part where Peyton has multitudes of both team and individual records and awards?
What is your point?
Posted on 2/8/16 at 1:20 pm to VFL1800FPD
And I agree, Peyton is top 5 all time. You just can't put him ahead of Montana and Brady because of his SB struggles.
Posted on 2/8/16 at 1:32 pm to AlabamaAlum07
Well I didn't
There's certainly an argument for him being GOAT, but that's exactly what it would devolve into, another stupid Rant argument haha
There's certainly an argument for him being GOAT, but that's exactly what it would devolve into, another stupid Rant argument haha
Posted on 2/8/16 at 1:49 pm to AlabamaAlum07
That comment wasn't directed towards you AAlum....I just used your post as a place to direct my comment which was aimed at the idiots that earlier were saying Manning is GOAT.
Posted on 2/8/16 at 1:59 pm to VFL1800FPD
Only player to get to the Super Bowl with 4 different coaches
Only Player to win the SB with 2 different teams.
Only player to have 5 NFL MVPs
Only player to throw 55 Tds in a single season
Only QB to reach 200 wins
Posted on 2/8/16 at 2:02 pm to presidenthog
quote:Saints players disagree, walked off the field without shaking any hands after that loss.
peyton is a stand up, class act
Posted on 2/8/16 at 2:07 pm to TT9
quote:
TT9
I bet you're so upset today
Posted on 2/8/16 at 2:16 pm to rockytop627
I'm just fine, thanks. 
Posted on 2/8/16 at 2:22 pm to TT9
Peyton was no question one of the all-time greats. He just happened to always have bad games against a particular team. His legacy, in my opinion, is tied unfairly to the Belichick/Brady cart.
We have an organization in New England that has been caught red-handed on at least two occasions bending the rules, but are revered by the national media, while the narrative was Peyton can't win the big games. Unfortunately for Peyton, by the time he had a complete team around him capable of winning those games, his body was falling apart and he couldn't get it done.
I hope time is friendly to Peyton, I really do. Glad his lasting Super Bowl memory was a win and not another Seattle performance.
We have an organization in New England that has been caught red-handed on at least two occasions bending the rules, but are revered by the national media, while the narrative was Peyton can't win the big games. Unfortunately for Peyton, by the time he had a complete team around him capable of winning those games, his body was falling apart and he couldn't get it done.
I hope time is friendly to Peyton, I really do. Glad his lasting Super Bowl memory was a win and not another Seattle performance.
Posted on 2/8/16 at 2:30 pm to RTRLSD
I actually thought he played fairly well. Both D's wreaked havoc on the O's but Peyton did all right. He may've actually been able to score if D Thomas didn't coat his hands in Vaseline before the game.
Page 5 of 5
Popular
Back to top
Follow SECRant for SEC Football News