Started By
Message
Mike Evans >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> ODB JR
Posted on 12/29/14 at 3:48 am
Posted on 12/29/14 at 3:48 am
Mike Evans 68 Receptions 1051 yds 15.5 Avg 12 TDs.
ODB JR 91 Receptions 1305 yds 14.3 Avg 12 TDS
Misc Stats:
Vincent Jackson 70 Receptions! Leading Receivers after Jackson and Evans have 30-20 Receptions.
Ruben Randle 71 receptions! Larry Odonnell 63. Preston Parker 36.
QBs: Eli Manning 63.1 Comp % 30 TDs 14 Ints.
Josh Mcclown 56.3 Comp % 11 TDS 14 ints.
Glennon: Sucks just as much albeit 10 TDS 6 Ints.
What I take from this? Give Evans more targets and a better QB he would put up far better numbers than ODB Jr. The Main threat outside of Evans is only Vincent Jackson. And Jackson missed some time this season. While the Giants almost had two receivers eclipse Evans in receptions with a two time Superbowl Champ throwing passes to them. I'll ignore the running game aspect as both teams were pretty bad, although NYG had a feature back.Two runningbacks for NYG had more carries then Tampa's leading rusher.
Eye Test: 5-11 198 vs 6-5 Monster? Who is the better blocker in run support? Lol Better hands? Debatable but I would take Evans in any jump ball/posession situation.Strength? Evans. Speed and shiftiness goes to ODB. Route Running I'd give a slight edge to ODB.
Final Verdict: In my opinion Mike Evans is the better player only slightly.But theyre on the same level. But in terms of ROY it will be probably be due to Stats and media hype over that catch, that ODB will win it.
Its 3ammmm I must be lonel--drunk.
ODB JR 91 Receptions 1305 yds 14.3 Avg 12 TDS
Misc Stats:
Vincent Jackson 70 Receptions! Leading Receivers after Jackson and Evans have 30-20 Receptions.
Ruben Randle 71 receptions! Larry Odonnell 63. Preston Parker 36.
QBs: Eli Manning 63.1 Comp % 30 TDs 14 Ints.
Josh Mcclown 56.3 Comp % 11 TDS 14 ints.
Glennon: Sucks just as much albeit 10 TDS 6 Ints.
What I take from this? Give Evans more targets and a better QB he would put up far better numbers than ODB Jr. The Main threat outside of Evans is only Vincent Jackson. And Jackson missed some time this season. While the Giants almost had two receivers eclipse Evans in receptions with a two time Superbowl Champ throwing passes to them. I'll ignore the running game aspect as both teams were pretty bad, although NYG had a feature back.Two runningbacks for NYG had more carries then Tampa's leading rusher.
Eye Test: 5-11 198 vs 6-5 Monster? Who is the better blocker in run support? Lol Better hands? Debatable but I would take Evans in any jump ball/posession situation.Strength? Evans. Speed and shiftiness goes to ODB. Route Running I'd give a slight edge to ODB.
Final Verdict: In my opinion Mike Evans is the better player only slightly.But theyre on the same level. But in terms of ROY it will be probably be due to Stats and media hype over that catch, that ODB will win it.
Its 3ammmm I must be lonel--drunk.
26
Posted on 12/29/14 at 3:56 am to Fuegoqueso
No not really.
Posted on 12/29/14 at 4:04 am to Fuegoqueso
You really thought this response thread was a good idea? 
ETA: Let me have the honor of giving you your first downvote before the LSU fans wake up to catch the short bus.
ETA: Let me have the honor of giving you your first downvote before the LSU fans wake up to catch the short bus.
This post was edited on 12/29/14 at 4:06 am
Posted on 12/29/14 at 4:23 am to Fuegoqueso
Take off your Aggot colored glasses., ODB and it's not even close. Your own stats prove it Einstein. Also ODB played in 4 less games.
Posted on 12/29/14 at 4:26 am to MadDoggyStyle
Is that what that stat tells you?
It tells me your 6'5" monster can't get open enough to warrant more passes.
It tells me your 6'5" monster can't get open enough to warrant more passes.
Posted on 12/29/14 at 4:32 am to Fuegoqueso
Still never won anything with him.
Posted on 12/29/14 at 5:02 am to Fuegoqueso
Mike Evans got shut down by a 160lb freshman cornerback.
Posted on 12/29/14 at 5:13 am to Fuegoqueso
You're on crack
Posted on 12/29/14 at 5:18 am to Fuegoqueso
(no message)
This post was edited on 3/18/21 at 9:07 am
Posted on 12/29/14 at 5:19 am to Fuegoqueso
Posted. In other thread:
How about yards per game stats?
Rk Player Team Pos Rec Yds Avg Yds/G Lng TD 20+ 40+ 1st 1
1 Odell Beckham NYG WR 91 1,305 14.3 108.8 80T 12 16 6
2 Julio Jones ATL WR 104 1,593 15.3 106.2 79 6 31 3 76
3 Antonio Brown PIT WR 129 1,698 13.2 106.1 63T 13 19 4 85
4 Demaryius Thomas DEN WR 111 1,619 14.6 101.2 86T 11 25 6
5 Jordy Nelson GB WR 98 1,519 15.5 94.9 80T 13 19 8 71 7
6 T.Y. Hilton IND WR 82 1,345 16.4 89.7 73T 7 21 6 62 75.6 3
7 Emmanuel Sanders DEN WR 101 1,404 13.9 87.8 48 9 24 4 69
8 Golden Tate DET WR 99 1,331 13.4 83.2 73T 4 17 5 58 58
9 Calvin Johnson DET WR 71 1,077 15.2 82.8 67T 8 16 3 59
10 Dez Bryant DAL WR 88 1,320 15.0
18 Mike Evans TB WR 68 1,051 15.5 70.1 56T 12 20 4 46 67
FYI, OBJ had 108.8 YPG and Evans had 70.1 YPG.
How about yards per game stats?
Rk Player Team Pos Rec Yds Avg Yds/G Lng TD 20+ 40+ 1st 1
1 Odell Beckham NYG WR 91 1,305 14.3 108.8 80T 12 16 6
2 Julio Jones ATL WR 104 1,593 15.3 106.2 79 6 31 3 76
3 Antonio Brown PIT WR 129 1,698 13.2 106.1 63T 13 19 4 85
4 Demaryius Thomas DEN WR 111 1,619 14.6 101.2 86T 11 25 6
5 Jordy Nelson GB WR 98 1,519 15.5 94.9 80T 13 19 8 71 7
6 T.Y. Hilton IND WR 82 1,345 16.4 89.7 73T 7 21 6 62 75.6 3
7 Emmanuel Sanders DEN WR 101 1,404 13.9 87.8 48 9 24 4 69
8 Golden Tate DET WR 99 1,331 13.4 83.2 73T 4 17 5 58 58
9 Calvin Johnson DET WR 71 1,077 15.2 82.8 67T 8 16 3 59
10 Dez Bryant DAL WR 88 1,320 15.0
18 Mike Evans TB WR 68 1,051 15.5 70.1 56T 12 20 4 46 67
FYI, OBJ had 108.8 YPG and Evans had 70.1 YPG.
Posted on 12/29/14 at 5:20 am to RadTiger
Not sure why you posted that to me.
Posted on 12/29/14 at 5:22 am to graychef
quote:
Just imagine if Beckham got to play against the Saints and Falcons four times.
Haha no shite.
So OP is saying if he had his choice in player he would take Evans over Beckham. Haha.
Posted on 12/29/14 at 5:27 am to GatorReb
Lol
This post was edited on 12/29/14 at 5:28 am
Posted on 12/29/14 at 5:42 am to Fuegoqueso
OP so dumb bro. fricking idiot
Posted on 12/29/14 at 6:10 am to Fuegoqueso
Route running is a massive edge to beckham. He's a better blocker too despite being much smaller. Evans can go get it and has nice wheels for a big guy. Evans and Beckham both look like they could be top 5 wrs soon if they stay on this path.
Posted on 12/29/14 at 6:30 am to rmnldr
quote:
Mike Evans got shut down by a 160lb freshman cornerback.
OBJ got shutdown by Cyrus Jones. 3 for 42 yards.
Mike Evans had 7 for 280 and a TD.
Posted on 12/29/14 at 6:31 am to Recruitingjunkie
Who gives a shite anyways.
Cooper and Julio > everyone
Cooper and Julio > everyone
Posted on 12/29/14 at 6:36 am to MadDoggyStyle
The only good point that was made was the YPG stat. Based on that list I'd still take 8-9 receivers over him including Evans.
He couldnt get open enough? Thats what it tells you!? /yawn
Mizzou fan telling me "never won anything with him" Granted you guys do have A&M's number, but you guys are the kings of choking football championships, so thats pretty rich coming from you guys. But making the championship game counts, so you got that going for you then. (Too lazy to edit meant *Conference championships)
Freshman Corner? Quit living in the past.
Saints and Falcons? Granted they are the shittiest D's in the league. Its pretty much a moot point as the entire NFC east is bottom half. Could even say close to bottom quarter.
I enjoy the classy LSU fan comments however.
Easy Money I totally agree.
We'll see in the coming years..... as one season does not make a player.
He couldnt get open enough? Thats what it tells you!? /yawn
Mizzou fan telling me "never won anything with him" Granted you guys do have A&M's number, but you guys are the kings of choking football championships, so thats pretty rich coming from you guys. But making the championship game counts, so you got that going for you then. (Too lazy to edit meant *Conference championships)
Freshman Corner? Quit living in the past.
Saints and Falcons? Granted they are the shittiest D's in the league. Its pretty much a moot point as the entire NFC east is bottom half. Could even say close to bottom quarter.
I enjoy the classy LSU fan comments however.
Easy Money I totally agree.
We'll see in the coming years..... as one season does not make a player.
Posted on 12/29/14 at 6:53 am to Fuegoqueso
ODB missed four games this year and still had better stats than Evans.
Posted on 12/29/14 at 6:56 am to RadTiger
Or he has VJax on the other side, who also warrants alot of passes....
Page 1 of 3
Popular
Back to top
Follow SECRant for SEC Football News