Alabama Football: Are Alabama's High Picks Falling Short? | SECRant.com
menu
Posted by
Message
Chizzin' ain't Easy
USA Fan
Member since Oct 2012
474 posts

Alabama Football: Are Alabama's High Picks Falling Short?

I do not agree with the article, but I thought it would bring some valuable discussion. What players, from the recent Alabama teams, do you consider busts at this point? Who do you consider successes? Who needs more time? Who has the potential to have a great career? Who needs a new start? These could all be focal points of a great discussion.

Alabama Football: Are Alabama's High Picks Falling Short?
quote:

quote:

No. 1: Lack of Saban-Like Discipline
What happens when the players step away from that team-first environment? What happens when they go from being one part of a big team to one employee of a big team and are left to their own devices? Sometimes, they’ve bought in to the Alabama way to such a great extent that they’re immediately lost the moment they step away from it.
quote:

quote:

No. 2: Unused to a Lack of Success
While McClain’s fellow Crimson Tide first-round draft picks didn’t flame out as spectacularly as he did, they too might have been caught just as unprepared for adversity in the NFL.
quote:

quote:

No. 3: Better Team Players Than Star Players?
Maybe all those Alabama defensive players that have been selected in the NFL draft in recent years appeared much better in college because of the talent next to them and the way Saban used their talents instead of having the ability to excel at the next level. Take Terrence Cody, who dominated as a defensive tackle for the Crimson Tide but struggled mightily last year for the Baltimore Ravens.
Also see: Courtney Upshaw's weight issue.
This post was edited on 6/14 at 1:48 pm



Teague
Alabama Fan
Huntsville, AL
Member since Aug 2007
11381 posts

re: Alabama Football: Are Alabama's High Picks Falling Short?
Who cares? frick the NFL.


Replies (0)
Replies (0)
RockyMtnTigerWDE
USA Fan
PosiBarner CO-Captain
Member since Oct 2010
52909 posts

re: Alabama Football: Are Alabama's High Picks Falling Short?
I am not sure, but I believe this issue has been discussed before.


JuiceTerry
Alabama Fan
Roond the Scheme
Member since Apr 2013
11268 posts
Online

re: Alabama Football: Are Alabama's High Picks Falling Short?
Agree with all. So I guess Saban is pretty good.


CapstoneGrad06
Alabama Fan
Little Rock, Arkansas
Member since Nov 2008
46463 posts

re: Alabama Football: Are Alabama's High Picks Falling Short?
quote:

but I thought it would bring some valuable discussion.


You know exactly what it will do on this board. And that's not one of them.


Alahunter
Alabama Fan
Member since Jan 2008
87801 posts
Online

re: Alabama Football: Are Alabama's High Picks Falling Short?
Alabama does for them what they're supposed to do for them. Getting them degrees, drafted high and championship rings. Like any other adult, when they get on their own, it's up to them.


lowspark12
Auburn Fan
nashville, tn
Member since Aug 2009
15754 posts

re: Alabama Football: Are Alabama's High Picks Falling Short?
very true.

with that said, they've had some high profile busts... but some guys are doing well and will do well in the future... hightower will be great in NE... richardson's well on his way to being the best back in the league... warmack will do well in TN.


CapstoneGrad06
Alabama Fan
Little Rock, Arkansas
Member since Nov 2008
46463 posts

re: Alabama Football: Are Alabama's High Picks Falling Short?
But other than McClain, who failed massively, who's even been in the NFL long enough to judge? Andre Smith? Well, he's one of the best RTs in the NFL. The best OL the Bengals have. Kareem Jackson was in the 2010 draft class with McClain and has started. But hasn't lived up to 1st round material just yet. The guys in the 2011, 2012, and obviously 2013 haven't even gotten started yet.


mwlewis
Ole Miss Fan
Bham
Member since Nov 2010
17708 posts

re: Alabama Football: Are Alabama's High Picks Falling Short?
quote:

I believe this issue has been discussed before.


Replies (0)
Replies (0)
Tennessee Jed
Tennessee Fan
Mr. SEC Rant
Member since Nov 2009
16733 posts

re: Alabama Football: Are Alabama's High Picks Falling Short?
It's eventually going to be their demise. Sure the draft picks look pretty now, but they're turning out to be 100%, garaunteed busts. It's becoming a talking point, and that is not good for the Tide.


CapstoneGrad06
Alabama Fan
Little Rock, Arkansas
Member since Nov 2008
46463 posts

re: Alabama Football: Are Alabama's High Picks Falling Short?
quote:

with that said, they've had some high profile busts... but some guys are doing well and will do well in the future... hightower will be great in NE... richardson's well on his way to being the best back in the league... warmack will do well in TN.



Which is what I was getting at. But like fans, the media is far too short-sighted and impatient. They're ready to label someone a bust, or not, after one year in the NFL. Like recruiting classes in college, the draft grade doesn't come until down the road.


Replies (0)
Replies (0)
lowspark12
Auburn Fan
nashville, tn
Member since Aug 2009
15754 posts

re: Alabama Football: Are Alabama's High Picks Falling Short?
has Smith resigned with Cincinnati?


CapstoneGrad06
Alabama Fan
Little Rock, Arkansas
Member since Nov 2008
46463 posts

re: Alabama Football: Are Alabama's High Picks Falling Short?
quote:

It's eventually going to be their demise. Sure the draft picks look pretty now, but they're turning out to be 100%, garaunteed busts. It's becoming a talking point, and that is not good for the Tide.



Did you type that with a straight face?


Replies (0)
Replies (0)
CapstoneGrad06
Alabama Fan
Little Rock, Arkansas
Member since Nov 2008
46463 posts

re: Alabama Football: Are Alabama's High Picks Falling Short?
quote:

has Smith resigned with Cincinnati?



He re-signed in April.


Replies (0)
Replies (0)
c on z
New Orleans Pelicans Fan
Baton Rouge, La.
Member since Mar 2009
75445 posts
Online

re: Alabama Football: Are Alabama's High Picks Falling Short?
quote:

The guys in the 2011, 2012, and obviously 2013 haven't even gotten started yet.


It's kinda safe to say that Ingram was drafted too high.
This post was edited on 6/14 at 1:58 pm


RockyMtnTigerWDE
USA Fan
PosiBarner CO-Captain
Member since Oct 2010
52909 posts

re: Alabama Football: Are Alabama's High Picks Falling Short?
quote:

It's eventually going to be their demise.


I know what you're getting at, but how is it Saban's fault the kids don't perform in the NFL once they are taken in the draft. I would hate Saban too for giving me a chance to make millions playing football.

However, the Auburn in me hopes you are right...


coachcrisp
Alabama Fan
pensacola, fl
Member since Jun 2012
5387 posts

re: Alabama Football: Are Alabama's High Picks Falling Short?
Ditto. It's laughable to attempt to make any type of reasonable argument using these stupid conjectures.


Replies (0)
Replies (0)
StopRobot
Mobile, AL
Member since May 2013
4872 posts

re: Alabama Football: Are Alabama's High Picks Falling Short?
I will never understand McClain. Probably the most NFL ready player Bama has had in last 10 years. Just everything seemed to be there. Incredible athletic ability, ran the defense on the field.


3legr
Texas A&M Fan
Member since Jan 2012
232 posts

re: Alabama Football: Are Alabama's High Picks Falling Short?
Thought this was about receiver picks. Carry on.


Replies (0)
Replies (0)
lowspark12
Auburn Fan
nashville, tn
Member since Aug 2009
15754 posts

re: Alabama Football: Are Alabama's High Picks Falling Short?
i mean the thought that this will be their 'demise'... come on. It's far more likely to come with stuff like crappy QB development or assistant coaches leaving (namely smart)... not because they've had a ton of early rounders not live up to the hype... ... you could even spin that into a positive.


Page 1 2 3 4 5
Jump to page
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 5next pagelast page

Back to top

logoFollow SECRant for SEC Football News
Follow us on Twitter and Facebook to get the latest updates on SEC Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitter