Started By
Message

WDE24's Top 5 SEC RB's Week 5

Posted on 9/30/14 at 10:02 am
Posted by WDE24
Member since Oct 2010
54132 posts
Posted on 9/30/14 at 10:02 am
Due to its growing popularity, the demand from fans across the country and the committee's schedule, the list is out a day early this week.

As always this list chronicles the top SEC running backs by production on the field to date for the current season. Objective statistics are the primary criteria utilized in formulating this list, however, the statistics are set into context based on the quality of opponent upon which the statistics were accumulated. In some instances where the choice is close, a subjective eye test is also taken into account. However, hype, injuries, suspensions, etc. are not. This isn't a list of most talented or a prediction of NFL draft status. It is just an unbiased look at which 5 SEC RB's are getting the job done the best on the field. As such, this list will likely drastically change each week, especially early in the season.

Note: This list only looks at performance at the RB position. Thus, kick and punt return yardage aren't part of the evaluation. However, receiving out of the RB position is accounted for.

1. Todd Gurley - After feeling snubbed by the committee last week, Gurley was motivated to reassert himself atop this list. His performance against UTk was more than enough to do so.

2. Alex Collins - This was the closest decision this week for the committee and numbers 2 and 3 were flip flopped several times in the deliberations. However, level of competition matters and the committee just couldn't ignore the big difference in the number of decent teams Collins has run against to the single quality opponent faced by Robinson.

3. Josh Robinson - Robinson did everything he could to validate his numbers by having his best game against LSU. However, a bye week coupled with 3 cupcakes keeps him from being number 2 by the narrowest of margins.

4. Cameron Artis-Payne - His yards per game from scrimmage numbers are better than Collins', but Collins and Robinson have been more efficient and explosive. Some homers (hg) believe that LF's 81 yards per game with his best game of 155 yards against NMSU should be ahead of CAP at this point. However, CAP's resume with 133 per game with 193 against Arkansas is still far superior at this point.

5. Jonathan Williams - This was a tough call as there were about 5 backs with similar production. However, Williams efficiency and competition level had him narrowly edge out those listed below.

Worth a mention:

Jalen Hurd, Mike Davis, Matt Jones, Derrick Henry, and Russell Hansborough.
This post was edited on 9/30/14 at 10:05 am
Posted by Eric Nies Grind Time
Atlanta GA - ITP
Member since Sep 2012
24932 posts
Posted on 9/30/14 at 10:04 am to
Tweeting this to Robinson for motivation.
Posted by parkjas2001
Gustav Fan Club: Consigliere
Member since Feb 2010
45000 posts
Posted on 9/30/14 at 10:04 am to
Solid list 1-5


I think Hurd is going to creep into the Top 5 soon though.

CAP/Robinson has a real chance the next two weeks to get that #2 spot.
Posted by Tornado Alley
Member since Mar 2012
26480 posts
Posted on 9/30/14 at 10:04 am to
Always a staple of tRant.

Well done, WDE
Posted by WDE24
Member since Oct 2010
54132 posts
Posted on 9/30/14 at 10:06 am to
Hurd has impressed the committee with his hard nosed running, but his yards per touch numbers were too low to put him ahead of others at this point.

However, his two best games have come against UT's best competition, so he is rightfully knocking on the door.
This post was edited on 9/30/14 at 10:08 am
Posted by Tennessee Jed
Mr. SEC Rant
Member since Nov 2009
17909 posts
Posted on 9/30/14 at 10:07 am to
quote:

I think Hurd is going to creep into the Top 5 soon though.


He's improved every game, and honestly, that's all you can ask of a true freshman.

I know it's been said a number of times, but what he's done behind our OL is extremely impressive.
Posted by WG_Dawg
Hoover
Member since Jun 2004
86428 posts
Posted on 9/30/14 at 10:08 am to
WHERE WERE YOU YESTERDAY
Posted by parkjas2001
Gustav Fan Club: Consigliere
Member since Feb 2010
45000 posts
Posted on 9/30/14 at 10:08 am to
I am sure the committee took into account his fumble that gave UGA the win.
Posted by SECSolomonGrundy
Slaughter Swamp
Member since Jun 2012
15808 posts
Posted on 9/30/14 at 10:09 am to
quote:

I think Hurd is going to creep into the Top 5 soon


:kige:
Posted by WDE24
Member since Oct 2010
54132 posts
Posted on 9/30/14 at 10:09 am to
Indeed. The committee looks at all production from the RB position and fumbles are considered.
Posted by hg
Member since Jun 2009
123554 posts
Posted on 9/30/14 at 10:10 am to
quote:

Some homers (hg) believe that LF's 81 yards per game with his best game of 155 yards against NMSU should be ahead of CAP at this point. However, CAP's resume with 133 per game with 193 against Arkansas is still far superior at this point.


Posted by WDE24
Member since Oct 2010
54132 posts
Posted on 9/30/14 at 10:11 am to
Posted by Tennessee Jed
Mr. SEC Rant
Member since Nov 2009
17909 posts
Posted on 9/30/14 at 10:13 am to
quote:

Indeed. The committee looks at all production from the RB position and fumbles are considered.


I've actually been looking forward to this thread, and I assumed that fumble would keep him out of the top 5, and I totally think that's a fair assessment.

The SEC is absurdly deep at RB right now. When you have supremely talented guys like Chubb, Michel, and Roc Thomas not even breaking into the honorable mention list, that really says something.
Posted by TexasAg13
San Antonio de Béxar
Member since Jul 2013
5815 posts
Posted on 9/30/14 at 10:15 am to
I'll take Derrick Henry over everyone not named Gurley.
Posted by parkjas2001
Gustav Fan Club: Consigliere
Member since Feb 2010
45000 posts
Posted on 9/30/14 at 10:15 am to
Well to be honest, Roc has not gotten into the rotation yet. He is returning KOs though.
Posted by WDE24
Member since Oct 2010
54132 posts
Posted on 9/30/14 at 10:16 am to
The committee understands that sentiment. As addressed in the op, this list is about acknowledging production, not just talent or potential.
Posted by slacker130
Your mom
Member since Jul 2010
7980 posts
Posted on 9/30/14 at 10:19 am to
Cue the outrage in 5,4,3,2....
Posted by WDE24
Member since Oct 2010
54132 posts
Posted on 9/30/14 at 10:24 am to
I don't think there is much to disagree with here. There is room maybe to debate whether 2 and 3 should be flipped and maybe which of about 6 guys should be at 5, but this week there isn't any real controversy.
Posted by TheCheshireHog
Cashew Chicken Country
Member since Oct 2010
40851 posts
Posted on 9/30/14 at 10:25 am to
quote:

The committee understands that sentiment. As addressed in the op, this list is about acknowledging production, not just talent or potential.


It's amazing how often this has to be repeated.
This post was edited on 9/30/14 at 10:26 am
Posted by slacker130
Your mom
Member since Jul 2010
7980 posts
Posted on 9/30/14 at 10:26 am to
quote:

I don't think there is much to disagree with here. There is room maybe to debate whether 2 and 3 should be flipped and maybe which of about 6 guys should be at 5, but this week there isn't any real controversy.


Well, your list sucks then. It should be in the committee's charter to make someone mad.
Page 1 2
Jump to page
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 2Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow SECRant for SEC Football News
Follow us on Twitter and Facebook to get the latest updates on SEC Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitter