Started By
Message
Archie, Eli, & Peyton: Who Was the Best Manning (College Only)
Posted on 8/5/14 at 2:16 pm
Posted on 8/5/14 at 2:16 pm
I'm surprised this debate does not come up more often, kinda like Bo vs Herschel (the answer is Bo).
There was a discussion of Archie earlier on one of the local radio shows which made the point that Ole Miss was at it's peak when he was there and even though Eli won a share of the SECw they've never had the same level of success that they achieved under Archie
I think it's a draw between Archie and Peyton?
There was a discussion of Archie earlier on one of the local radio shows which made the point that Ole Miss was at it's peak when he was there and even though Eli won a share of the SECw they've never had the same level of success that they achieved under Archie
I think it's a draw between Archie and Peyton?
17
Posted on 8/5/14 at 2:18 pm to undecided
quote:
Archie, Eli, & Peyton
...walk into a bar.
Posted on 8/5/14 at 2:18 pm to undecided
Danny.
Posted on 8/5/14 at 2:18 pm to undecided
Ole Miss wasn't at its peak when Archie was there. That was a decade earlier.
Archie is the best because he had the fewest resources around him.
Archie is the best because he had the fewest resources around him.
Posted on 8/5/14 at 2:19 pm to undecided
Archie Who by a landslide....
Posted on 8/5/14 at 2:22 pm to MetryTyger
No NCs for any college Manning, so
Archie.
Archie.
Posted on 8/5/14 at 2:22 pm to MetryTyger
Archie and I have 3 of his shirts to prove it. He was the dominant QB
Posted on 8/5/14 at 2:23 pm to mikrit54
quote:
Danny.
FTW
Posted on 8/5/14 at 2:24 pm to DingDongEddieStrong
quote:
Ole Miss wasn't at its peak when Archie was there. That was a decade earlier.
I think they were trying to say this was the last period Ole Miss was nationally relevant?
Posted on 8/5/14 at 2:27 pm to undecided
Not to derail but hoping an Ole Miss or Tennessee fan can briefly explain why Peyton went to Rocky Top instead of Oxford?
Did Ole Miss not recruit him or what? I didn't follow SEC recruiting and all that back then and I'm curious.
Btw, it has to be Archie.
Did Ole Miss not recruit him or what? I didn't follow SEC recruiting and all that back then and I'm curious.
Btw, it has to be Archie.
Posted on 8/5/14 at 2:27 pm to undecided
With all the talent Fulmer had during Manning's run it's amazing he didn't win at least one title but Fla was pretty loaded as well. They did win it the year after Manning was gone but they beat a FSU team that would have manhandled that Tenn team with a healthy QB. Fla - Tenn battles similar to the recent LSU - Bama battles.
Would be nice to see those two teams get back to where they were when the east was so dominant.
Would be nice to see those two teams get back to where they were when the east was so dominant.
Posted on 8/5/14 at 2:29 pm to undecided
quote:
Bo vs Herschel (the answer is Herschel).
FIFY
Posted on 8/5/14 at 2:30 pm to undecided
quote:
I think it's a draw between Archie and Peyton?
Archie
Posted on 8/5/14 at 2:30 pm to AgCoug
I think he wanted to make his own legacy.
Posted on 8/5/14 at 2:31 pm to Summer of George
quote:
...walk into a bar.
....and see Johnny Football at the bar.....
Posted on 8/5/14 at 2:31 pm to AgCoug
Peyton didn't attend Ole Miss due to probation and Cooper's spinal problem that ended his career.
Posted on 8/5/14 at 2:34 pm to nicholastiger
quote:
With all the talent Fulmer had during Manning's run it's amazing he didn't win at least one title
I wonder if Peyton is regarded any differently if he wins either a NC or a Heisman while in college?
Posted on 8/5/14 at 2:36 pm to undecided
Eli.
he had no body to help him.
he had no body to help him.
Posted on 8/5/14 at 2:37 pm to pankReb
Should have won the Heisman that year
Posted on 8/5/14 at 2:38 pm to nicholastiger
Peyton and Archie were two completely different types of qb it's hard to compare them.
Page 1 of 6
Popular
Back to top
Follow SECRant for SEC Football News