Started By
Message
Where does the big 4 Ms and Connor Shaw rank among QB grad classes in the past?
Posted on 5/25/14 at 1:35 am
Posted on 5/25/14 at 1:35 am
McCarron - GOAT at Bama no contest
Murray - Don't know how UGA fans feel about him history wise. I would say GOAT though. Tough as nails and was oh so close to having a chance at raping Notre Dame in the BCSNG.
Mettenburger - NFL size and arm and had a fairly decent year. Don't know how he compared historically in LSU's QB history but definitely a solid QB.
Manziel - ummmmmmmm yeah. GOAT
Connor Shaw -
Dudes a boss. My personal favorite SCAR player ever. If I remember correctly, he is in the top 2 or 3 of the winningest QBs ever at SC? Correct me if I'm wrong.
So what would y'all say?
Murray - Don't know how UGA fans feel about him history wise. I would say GOAT though. Tough as nails and was oh so close to having a chance at raping Notre Dame in the BCSNG.
Mettenburger - NFL size and arm and had a fairly decent year. Don't know how he compared historically in LSU's QB history but definitely a solid QB.
Manziel - ummmmmmmm yeah. GOAT
Connor Shaw -
Dudes a boss. My personal favorite SCAR player ever. If I remember correctly, he is in the top 2 or 3 of the winningest QBs ever at SC? Correct me if I'm wrong. So what would y'all say?
6
Posted on 5/25/14 at 1:37 am to FourThreeForty
quote:
If I remember correctly, he is in the top 2 or 3 of the winningest QBs ever at SC?
He has the most wins ever as a QB in South Carolina history now after this past season.
This post was edited on 5/25/14 at 1:38 am
Posted on 5/25/14 at 1:37 am to FourThreeForty
Connor Shaw is the winningest South Carolina QB. Also never lost a game in Williams-Brice.
Posted on 5/25/14 at 1:37 am to FourThreeForty
quote:1st, actually. And yes, SC's best QB ever.
Connor Shaw - Dudes a boss. My personal favorite SCAR player ever. If I remember correctly, he is in the top 2 or 3 of the winningest QBs ever at SC? Correct me if I'm wrong.
Posted on 5/25/14 at 1:40 am to CockRocket
So possibly 4 GOATS.....interesting to see how this'll turn out 
Posted on 5/25/14 at 1:56 am to FourThreeForty
quote:
So possibly 4 GOATS
lolno
Posted on 5/25/14 at 1:57 am to FourThreeForty
quote:
McCarron
Statistically Alabama's greatest ever.
quote:
Murray
Statistically Georgia's greatest ever
quote:
Mettenburger
Decent, but far from LSU's best ever. I would rank him below Rohan Davey and Matt Mauck. Closer to Herb Tyler.
quote:
Manziel
We all saw what he did.
quote:
Shaw
Was good. Steve Taneyhill is still my all-time favorite from USC, followed by Phil Petty.
Posted on 5/25/14 at 2:02 am to harmonics
Btw, this is strictly college. No pro success or any garbage like that. Because they obviously can't be compared at the moment.
Posted on 5/25/14 at 2:06 am to FourThreeForty
I think Brodie Croyle would have been an All-American had he played under Saban in this system, especially if he had the 2012 offensive-line. He could have easily duplicated AJs numbers, if not exceeded them. McCarron was fortunate to play at Alabama at a time like this.
Posted on 5/25/14 at 2:09 am to FourThreeForty
Jamarcus never won a nc, but he was the GOAT at lsu.
Posted on 5/25/14 at 2:10 am to harmonics
Brodie had a hell of an arm too. That 2005 Auburn game scarred him for life....Thank god they lost their bowl game that year to Wisky or Nebraska....that was not a fun game for me....
Posted on 5/25/14 at 2:10 am to FourThreeForty
Mettenburger was decent but we have had better,
YA Tittle Bert Jones Alan Risher Jeff Wickersham Tommy Hodson Rohan Davey Matt Mauck Matt Flynn Herb Tyler
Tommy Hodson holds most of our QB records
YA Tittle Bert Jones Alan Risher Jeff Wickersham Tommy Hodson Rohan Davey Matt Mauck Matt Flynn Herb Tyler
Tommy Hodson holds most of our QB records
This post was edited on 5/25/14 at 2:13 am
Posted on 5/25/14 at 2:11 am to harmonics
Mett ranks behind Hodson, Russell, Davey, Flynn, Mauk, Jones, and Tittle. He would be somewhere in the bottom half of the top 10, IMO.
Posted on 5/25/14 at 2:13 am to geauxnavybeatbama
Hockey....all of it. Matt jones was the most creative quarterback the SEC has seen in the past decade. I'm sorry but none of the people here mentioned could do what lanky long legged Matt Jones did for Arkansas. Scrambling around on a wing and a prayer. whoopin texas like they owed him money. None of those 5 were game changers. Most aren't better than the quarterback we got right now.
J. Holly Blasingame, II
J. Holly Blasingame, II
Posted on 5/25/14 at 2:34 am to geauxnavybeatbama
Rohan Davey will haunt me for ever, in regards to LSU qbs. What he and Josh Reed did to Alabama in 2001 is unforgettable. Similar to Manziel/Evans this past year. It is amazing what a mismatch between a WR/CB will do to a defense.
Posted on 5/25/14 at 2:39 am to pondwater jack
Matt jones ran for a TD against texas and flipped the ball begin his back into the human mascot's face lol... I always liked how he played, but he was a terrible passer.
Posted on 5/25/14 at 2:40 am to harmonics
I still hear "Rohan To Reed " in my dreams. Most lethal combo LSU ever had
Posted on 5/25/14 at 2:58 am to LSUNV
Michael Clayton had a huge game too. Was just an all around terrible day for the Alabama secondary.
Posted on 5/25/14 at 2:58 am to LSUNV
Coming up on 10,000 posts LSUNV. A congratulations is in order, with two more posts. 
Posted on 5/25/14 at 3:01 am to abellsujr
Thanks!
With this one 9999! Saving the 10000 for tomorrow's game!
With this one 9999! Saving the 10000 for tomorrow's game!
Page 1 of 2
Popular
Back to top
Follow SECRant for SEC Football News