Mac's recruiting and production

So you mean all these three star gems aren't solid gold? Man. That is surprising.

Its actually Proven they do. So no. They weren't.

Oh Lol. Gotcha.

Dude, just let it go. Hes a dumbass.

Notice he curved the grades to help fit his narrative

Gave a rotational DL about the same grade as Toney which in itself is a joke.

This is like borderline you're gonna send bombs in mailboxes type of post, man.

Your metric is also awful, and as usual only suits your narrative.

Hey man! Step off! He played for UF. So his football accumen is ten times that of yours...

But wait, how bout the opinion of Nick Saban? He said "Mac is great, I love him."

Ill take the opinion of lord Saban over any yahoo on a message board.

Ppl forget it was Macs offense that rolled over our number one Defense a few years back as Bama picked us apart. His offense at Colorado State was also a powerhouse. Yes id like to see us putting up 40 a game but with what players we have out now, its not happening. QB,RB,WRs... plus we lost Toney for the next game so expect more of the same.

Yeah injuries dont mater. Yet they cant answer why other HCs cant win when their qb goes down

2015
Ivey: A+
Scarlett: B-
AC81: B
Cronkrite: F
Jordan: C+
Williamson:D
Daniel I:F
Zuniga: A-
Sandifer:F
Knight:F
Jackson:D-
Ivie:F
Davis:D+
Buchanan:F
Johnson:B+
RDJ:F
Jackson:F
Ancrum: D-
McCoy: A
2016

Clayton:C
Cleveland:A
Gardner:A
Franks: B-
Swain: C+
Thompson: C+
Hammond:C
Moon:C+
Smith:F
TayLor:C+
Massey:F
Reese:A+
Wells:F-
Heggie:A-
Lenton:C
Joseph:B+
Polite:A+
Taylor:A+
Forsythe:C
Putu: C(good on special teams)
McWilliams: C
Pineiro:A+
Trask:C

On a true freshman scale
2017:
Slaton: A+
JRob: N/A
Carter:C
Henderson:A
Stewart:B
Wilson:A+
Green:C
Telfort:F
Moore:C
Gamble:C
Conliffe:B+
Davis:C+ (Who's this?)
Lemons:C+ (special teams contributor)
Toney:A+
Davis:A+
Campbell:A+ before injury
Allen:C
Miller:F
Edwards:C+
Houston:F
Stiner: C+
Smith:C
Brunson:C

Transfers:
LDR:B-
AA:C+
Zaire:D

How the frick can you give grades to transfers who aren't eligible until next year?
Dunlap: D
Delance:D

Totals:

A-A+:16
B-B+:8
C-C+:24
D-D+:5
F-F:13

This is how I would objectively rank the recruits that Mac has brought in. I think it's fair and more representative of the teams actual performance and talent level, and not subject to the agenda you're attempting to set in the OP. We'd obviously like the number of A and B level recruits to outnumber C-F, but I think we're much closer to that now than we would be if you compare this to say, Muschamp's recruiting classes. Especially on offense.

There's still work to do but I think it's too soon- at the point we're currently at- to be calling for Mac's head. I say make some coaching staff adjustments this offseason, which is something he's done a good job at in previous offseasons, and let's see how the team looks going forward. I'm still looking for improvement as the season goes on for us this year.

quote:

---

You mean like Smart? Seems he is fine losing his Qb and starting a true freshman

---

The replacement hasn't thrown for more than 125 years or more than 15 pass attempts in his career. They aren't doing what they're doing because of the quarterback. If we were doing what UGA is doing, there'd be Gator fans complaining that we don't throw the ball enough and the way we're playing is not sustainable.

I don't see the delusion. To me, delusion is expecting a team to go 12-0 and have a great offense without their best two WR's and best running back out due to suspension and injury, and the team's best defensive player out for the year with an injury.

Imagine the 2006 team without Percy Harvin and Dallas Baker, Deshaun Wynn, and Reggie Nelson. Would it be reasonable to expect Florida to win the national championship with that?

Boom!