Can we all agree to something about the QB situation?

Jalen will start the season as the starter. Won't last long. Tua is the real deal.

Jalen is/will put in the work to improve. The team has his back, unlike our fanbase, and he will continue to get ish done.

quote:

---

Jalen will start the season as the starter. Won't last long. Tua is the real deal.

---

quote:

---

Jalen didn't have anyone to push him to get better after Barnett left. He'll have some serious talent behind him this year.

---

Maybe so - but no point in spending the entire offseason talking about how trash a true freshman QB who won the SEC Championship and worked his arse off is.

If he doesn't improve and gets beat out, so be it. I'm not usually into caring what people think and their feelings, but can you imagine coming in as a true freshman, having the season Jalen did (and the season the team did) and spending the entire offseason reading how shitty you are and how some other freshman who has never taken a college snap is clearly better than you? Just seems kind of stupid.

You should expect Jalen to improve this year. He will have had another Spring to be coached up at the position. The game will "slow down" for him. In HS, a QB could hold the ball a little longer and throw it once the receiver is open. In college, you have to throw him open. Reading the entire field as opposed to splitting it in half or even a third in an attempt to limit mistakes.
These things should get better. He does have some talented young guys behind him and that should help him as well. "You either get better or worse with each passing day. You never stay the same."

Jalen had two issues that are very easily corrected with more comfort in what he's doing, this is not an ability issue

He doesn't trust his eyes yet and played timid in the passing game because of it. I don't think Jalen threw a receiver open all season. He needed to see that the guy was open before he turned it loose. It's hard to be efficient that way in the SEC regardless of the weapons at your disposal. The fact that we were able to move the ball anyway is a testament to those weapons and Kiffin.

What really doomed him with our message board fan base, and I'm not sure his is really debatable, he doesn't connect on the deep ball. Sims was great at it, Coker was really good at it by seasons end, and Jalen just couldn't hit one to save his life. I think at its core, this issue ties into issue number 1 more than an issue with talent or mechanics. He was overly cautious with the football because why wouldn't he be? He is an elite runner, why risk a throw you aren't confident in when you can scramble for a positive play. It's going to come with Jalen, I'm pretty confident in that. Most of his interceptions looked like short circuits where he either didn't see a guy or just had a panic/brain fart moment. The one at LSU, you could tell he made up his mind up where it was going and then tried to force it in there. That happens when you aren't comfortable. He's a hard working kid, the stuff he does on his own time will slow the game down and those "risky" throws will look easy to him. You hear soccer pundits talk about a players confidence all the time, as if it's right up there in terms of importance with his actual ability. You see closers/hitters in baseball get hot and gain confidence and they can really catch on fire. It's a huge part of professional athletics, it definitely impacts an 18 year old kid starting at quarterback for Alabama.

quote:

---

I think everyone is pulling for him but I agree if his ability to make reads and throw accurate passes doesn't improve the other two need to get a fair shake.

---

Agree - but I think we all need to just cool off and wait until that situation occurs. Kids generally make huge strides that first offseason, so the idea that he isn't going to get better seems silly. But, if he doesn't, or if he doesn't enough to be the QB we need, he should be passed on the depth chart. And I assume he will.

But nothing between now and August will change in terms of all that, so there's no point in rehashing it over and over.

quote:

---

The notion that he might not improve at all is pretty silly. I've been guilty of it as well at times. We all need to kind of take a step back and realize that hey, this was a true freshman football player. They almost always get better.

---

And if he doesn't, and we keep him there, then it's time to complain.

But he was a true freshman. I wish we hadn't been forced to play one, but he performed better than most true freshman, even elite ones. To expect much more than we got from him would be silly. Is it his ceiling? If so, he won't last much longer. If not, let's just see how things progress.

For once our QB situation is going to be solid. Doesn't matter who plays. Hurts, tua, mac is a better than hurts, cooper, Cornwell

Just shocked excluding jalen, how bad our coaches were at talent eval at the position.

Just imagine how bad it would've been if Coker didn't transfer.

quote:

---

Respectfully disagree. Jalen posted unheard of numbers for a true freshman, and even if he doesn't improve, he'll be the starter unless Tua just blows the staff away. I can agree that the best player will start, but I find it hilarious that people think Jalen (the SEC OPOY) wasn't good last year and that a true freshman that has proven nothing at the collegiate level will be much better. The Alabama fan base has an unhealthy obsession with the backup QB.

---

Agree with this 100 percent.


eta:

quote:

---

We can all agree to disagree. Most of us, that is, can do that.

---

I guarantee that you are on the posters that downvoted me for simply stating that I agreed with someone. Which is hilarious coming after the above statement.